Skip to content
OwnersBack

Bid checklists

What a roof replacement bid should include

The short answer

A complete roof replacement bid spells out a full tear-off, a set price per sheet for any rotted decking, the underlayment and shingle line by name, and new flashing and vents. It also says who pulls the permit, how cleanup works and how many years the workmanship warranty lasts. If your bid already covers most of that, you're in good shape, and the rest is a few questions.

Updated November 19, 2026

On this page
  1. What a complete bid spells out
  2. Vague lines worth a question
  3. A payment plan tied to finished work
  4. Comparing two or three bids
  5. Questions to ask before you sign
  6. Permits
  7. Common questions

What a complete bid spells out

Tick these off against your bid. Anything missing is worth a quick question before you sign.

0 of 13 found in my bid

Vague lines worth a question

  • “Replace damaged decking as needed”

    Ask for this in writingAsk for a price per sheet of plywood or OSB, how many sheets are included in the base price, and photos before any extra sheets go on.

  • “Install new architectural shingles”

    Ask for this in writingAsk for the maker's product line, color and warranty level written into the bid.

  • “Flashing as required”

    Ask for this in writingAsk which flashing is new (step, wall, chimney, drip edge and pipe boots) and which, if any, gets reused.

  • “Lifetime warranty”

    Ask for this in writingAsk whose warranty it is, how many years the workmanship part runs, what it covers and whether it transfers if you sell.

  • “Clean up job site”

    Ask for this in writingAsk for haul-off, tarps over landscaping and a magnetic nail sweep to be written in.

A payment plan tied to finished work

A roof often goes on in a few days, so payments should follow what you can see on the house, not the calendar. Keep the deposit modest, or your state's limit, if lower (see deposit limits by state), and hold the balance until the final inspection and cleanup are done. You can test any schedule with the payment schedule checker.

StageShare
Deposit at signing10%
Shingles and materials delivered to the house30%
Old roof off, decking repaired and underlayment on25%
Shingles, flashing and vents installed25%
Final inspection passed and yard cleaned upBalance
Check your own payment schedule →

Comparing two or three bids

  • Line up the same items across bids: layers coming off, underlayment, shingle line, flashing, vents and gutters, so you're not comparing a full job to a partial one.
  • Put each bid's price per sheet of decking side by side, since that number can move the final bill more than the headline price.
  • Check that every bid uses the same warranty level, because a higher level may need extra parts and a certified installer.
  • If one bid adds ridge vent or new skylight flashing and another doesn't mention it, ask both what your roof actually needs.
  • If one bid is much lower, ask what it leaves out before you call it the better deal, then run a free bid check on the one you're leaning toward.

Questions to ask before you sign

  1. 1How many layers are on the roof now, and will you tear everything off down to the deck?
  2. 2What's your price per sheet of decking, and will you send me photos before replacing any?
  3. 3Which shingle line, color and warranty level is this, and who registers the warranty?
  4. 4Are you certified by the shingle maker for that warranty level?
  5. 5Will all the flashing, drip edge and pipe boots be new?
  6. 6How will the attic be vented, and is there enough intake at the eaves?
  7. 7Who pulls the permit and schedules the final inspection?
  8. 8Will your own crew do the work, and do any subcontractors carry their own insurance?

Permits

Many cities and counties require a permit for a roof replacement, especially when decking is replaced or the roofing material changes, so check with your city or county building department. The licensed contractor should pull it and schedule the final inspection, as explained in who's responsible for permits.

Want a second set of eyes on your bid?

Upload your bid, a PDF or phone photos, and see in about a minute what it leaves out or leaves vague, quoted from your own pages. Free, no account.

Common questions

Should a roofing quote include plywood replacement?

It should include a price for it, even though nobody knows how many sheets you'll need until the old roof is off. Look for a set price per sheet and, ideally, a few sheets already in the base price. Ask the roofer to show you photos of soft spots before going past that number.

Is it okay to put a new roof over the old one?

Some local codes allow a second layer in certain cases, but a layover hides the deck and can limit some manufacturer warranties. If a bid proposes one, ask why, how many layers are on now and how it affects the warranty. Get the answer in writing.

What's the difference between a manufacturer warranty and a workmanship warranty?

The manufacturer covers defects in the shingles themselves. The workmanship warranty is the roofer's promise on the install, like leaks from flashing. A good bid lists both, with the years for each.

What should I check on a roof bid after a storm?

Read for any assignment of benefits or direction to pay before you sign, and ask how added items on the insurance claim get approved. It's fine to take a few days and get more than one bid. Our page on roofers who knock after a storm has more to ask.

My new roof leaks. What should the bid have covered?

Flashing, pipe boots, ice barrier and the workmanship warranty are the parts that matter most for leaks. If you're already dealing with one, see what to do when a new roof leaks.

These checklists describe common trade practice for a complete bid, not legal requirements. Rules vary by state and city.

Roof replacement bid checklist: what it should include | OwnersBack