Contractor disputes
Understand your options when a contractor lets you down.
Straight answers to the 100 questions homeowners ask most when a job goes wrong. Each one explains what the law says, what courts have decided, what to gather, and what to do next, with every statute and case linked to its source.
- questions answered
- 100
- verified laws and court cases
- 139
- states, plus DC
- 50
Find out where you stand in two minutes
Answer six quick questions. You'll see which claims usually fit your situation, the deadlines to watch, and the pages to read first. Nothing you choose is saved or sent anywhere.
Question 1 of 6
Most asked right now
- 1Can I sue my contractor for abandoning the job or not finishing it?Often, yes. If your contractor stopped work without a legal reason and you held up your end of the deal, you usually have a breach of contract claim for what it costs to finish and fix the job beyond what you still owed. The key condition is that you did not give the contractor a valid reason to stop, such as missing payments the contract required.
- 2My contractor took my deposit and disappeared. What can I do?Often, yes, you have a claim, but getting the money back is the hard part. A contractor who takes a deposit and does no work generally owes it back, and in some states keeping it with intent to defraud is a crime. How fast you act matters most, because card dispute windows, bond claims and recovery fund deadlines can be short.
- 3Can I fire my contractor in the middle of the job?Yes, you can usually end the relationship, but whether you owe the contractor money afterward depends on why you fired them. If the contractor seriously broke the contract, for example by abandoning the job or doing badly defective work, firing them is usually justified. If you fire them without a good legal reason, you may owe them for work done and possibly some of their lost profit.
- 4My contractor wants more money before finishing. Do I have to pay?Not always. If the contract has a fixed price and you did not ask for extra work, you generally do not have to pay more just to get the job finished. You may owe more if you approved changes, the contract allows price adjustments, or a truly unexpected condition came up that the contract makes your responsibility.
- 5Can a contractor go to jail for taking my money and not doing the work?Sometimes. Many states have laws that make it a crime for a contractor to take money with intent to defraud and then not do the work, or to divert job money. The catch is intent: a contractor who simply did a bad job or ran out of money usually faces a civil case, not a criminal one, and only a prosecutor can bring charges.
- 6Can I sue my contractor for bad workmanship?Often, yes. If your contractor's work falls below what the contract promised, or below the standard of a competent tradesperson, you can usually sue for the reasonable cost to fix it. The key conditions are proving the work is truly defective, usually with photos and an independent expert, and following any notice-and-repair steps your state requires before you file.
- 7My contractor won't fix their mistakes. What now?Often, yes, you may be able to make them pay even if they will not come back. If your contractor refuses to fix defective work, you can often hire someone else and seek the reasonable cost through a demand, a licensing board complaint, a bond claim or a lawsuit. First put the request in writing and follow any notice-and-repair law in your state, because skipping it can stall your case.
- 8My new roof leaks. Can I make the roofer pay?Often, yes. A new roof that leaks usually points to an installation problem, a defective product, or both, and when the roofer's work is the cause, you can often hold the roofer responsible for fixing it or paying for the repair. Report the leak in writing right away, and read both the roofer's workmanship warranty and the shingle maker's warranty, because each has its own rules and deadlines.
Every question, by problem
Search or pick a category.
Abandoned and unfinished jobs
14 questionsBad work and damage
14 questionsDeposits, bills and payments
12 questionsLiens on your home
10 questionsLicensing and unlicensed contractors
10 questionsContracts and cancelling
7 questionsDelays and permits
7 questionsBonds, funds and insurance
8 questionsSuing and collecting
18 questionsWhy bad contractors keep getting away with it, and how that changes
Most homeowners give up because they don't know their rights or miss a deadline. In most states you have more tools than a lawsuit:
- Licensing board complaints
- Contractor bonds
- State recovery funds
- Small claims court
- Consumer protection laws
- Criminal charges, in some cases
A contractor who reopens under a relative's name can still be reached. These pages show you how.
Hiring a new contractor to fix or finish the work? Check their bid free first.
State rules, side by side
Licensing boards, deposit limits, lien deadlines, recovery funds and small claims limits for all 50 states and DC.
Open the state rulesHow we research these pages
Every statute, regulation and court decision on these pages was read on an official or reputable source and checked word for word before we published it. If we couldn't verify something, we left it out. Each page shows the date we checked it. This is legal information, not legal advice, and OwnersBack isn't a law firm.