Skip to content
OwnersBack

Suing and collecting

My contractor is suing me for payment. What are my defenses?

The short answer

Your odds: Depends on the facts

You may have solid defenses, but do not ignore the lawsuit. Common defenses include unfinished or defective work, charges outside the contract, a contractor who was not licensed or registered, and a contract that broke your state's home improvement law, and you can often bring your own counterclaim. The key condition: you must respond by the court's deadline, or the contractor can win by default.

Steps to take
7
Laws and cases cited
18
Last checked

What to know

  • Respond to the lawsuit by the deadline on the papers, or you risk a default judgment.
  • Defective or unfinished work can reduce what you owe, and you can counterclaim for your losses.
  • In several states, an unlicensed or unregistered contractor cannot sue to get paid.
  • A contract that breaks your state's home improvement law may be unenforceable, though some states still let the contractor recover the value of its work.
  • If the contractor also filed a lien, beating the lien may let you recover attorney fees in some states.
On this page
  1. First, do not miss your deadline
  2. Defenses based on the work
  3. Licensing and registration defenses
  4. When the contract broke home improvement rules
  5. Counterclaims and liens
  6. Your state's rules, with sources
  7. What to gather
  8. What to do, step by step
  9. When to talk to a lawyer now
  10. Common follow-up questions
  11. Laws and cases on this page

The law, in detailTap a topic to open it.

First, do not miss your deadline

When you are served, the papers will say how long you have to respond. In small claims, that may mean showing up at a hearing; in a regular civil case, it usually means filing a written answer. If you miss it, the court can enter a default judgment against you. Read the papers the day you get them, write down the deadline, and if anything is unclear, call the court clerk or a lawyer right away. Check your contract for an arbitration clause too. Under federal law a written arbitration clause is generally enforceable, which can change where the case is heard[1]. See arbitration clauses.

Then gather your records and work out what you actually dispute. Many cases are about part of the bill, not all of it. Being clear about what you agree you owe and what you do not makes you more believable and can open the door to settlement.

    Defenses based on the work

    The most common defense is that the contractor did not hold up its end. If the work is unfinished or defective, what you owe may be reduced by the cost to finish or fix it. Courts often ask whether the contractor substantially performed. Wisconsin's Supreme Court let a builder recover the contract price minus the owners' damages, holding that substantial performance of a house contract does not require perfection[2]. That case cuts both ways: the builder won, but the owners got credit for missing items such as kitchen cabinets and gutters.

    For small, unintentional departures from the contract, your credit may be limited. New York's highest court held that when a builder used a different maker's pipe through a subcontractor's oversight, the owner's credit was the difference in the home's value, not the cost to tear out and replace it[3]. Deliberate or serious departures may be treated differently. Get an independent estimate to put a number on every defect. See when you can withhold payment.

    • Work never finished, or abandoned partway
    • Defective work that needs repair, backed by an estimate or inspection
    • Charges for extras with no written change order
    • Billing above the contract price or for work not done
    • Payments you already made that the bill does not credit

    Licensing and registration defenses

    In several states, a contractor who needed a license or registration and did not have it cannot sue you for payment. In Arizona, a contractor cannot sue in state court for work that requires a license unless it alleges and proves it was licensed both when the contract was made and when the claim arose[4]. In Florida, a contractor without the required state license cannot enforce the contract against you and has no lien or bond claim for that work[5]. In Washington, a contractor who had to be registered cannot sue to collect unless it proves it was properly registered when it contracted for the work[6].

    California's rule is among the strictest. The state licensing board says Business and Professions Code section 7031 stops an unlicensed contractor from using the courts to collect money from the customer, and lets a customer get back all the money paid to an unlicensed contractor[7]. California's Supreme Court has said judges may not use fairness arguments to get around section 7031, even when the result seems harsh to the contractor[8]; that older case was between two contracting businesses over equipment rentals on a road project, not a home job, and the statute has since been amended. The same court later held that an unlicensed contractor cannot get around the bar by calling its claim fraud when it is really about being paid for unlicensed work[9]. Courts do allow narrow exceptions, such as substantial compliance with licensing. These rules mainly block the contractor's lawsuit; getting your own money back, even in California, usually means bringing your own claim, and other states may allow unlicensed contractors some recovery. Check the contractor's license history for the whole job. See whether you have to pay an unlicensed contractor.

      When the contract broke home improvement rules

      Many states require home improvement contracts to be in writing and to include certain terms and a cancellation notice. What happens when they do not differs sharply by state. In Connecticut, the state Supreme Court held that a contract missing the Home Improvement Act's requirements cannot be enforced against the homeowner, and the contractor cannot recover the value of its work through unjust enrichment either[10]. But Connecticut later held that a homeowner who acts in bad faith, meaning with a dishonest purpose, cannot use the Act to escape paying[11].

      Pennsylvania goes the other way on recovery. Its Supreme Court held that a contractor whose contract met only three of the 13 requirements of the Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act could still sue for the reasonable value of its work, even though the contract itself could not be enforced[12]. So a missing term may help you, but it rarely means you owe nothing for work you accepted.

        Counterclaims and liens

        If the contractor's work cost you money, you can usually bring your own claims in the same case, such as breach of contract, breach of warranty or a consumer protection claim. Some pre-suit notice rules relax for counterclaims: the Massachusetts 30-day demand is not required for a counterclaim[13], and Texas's residential defect notice is excused when you raise the defect as a counterclaim[14]. See consumer protection claims.

        If the contractor also filed a mechanic's lien, the fight over the lien can carry its own fee rules. The Oklahoma Supreme Court held that homeowners who beat a lien foreclosure were entitled to a reasonable attorney fee under a state statute, even though they lost their own claim[15]. In Texas lien suits, the court awards costs and reasonable attorney fees as are equitable and just, and on a residential construction contract it is not required to order the owner to pay the contractor's fees[16]. See what to do about a lien on your house.

          Your state's rules, with sources

          Pick your state to see the rules that matter here, each linked to its official source.

          What to gather

          Tick things off as you collect them. Your list stays on this device only.

          0 of 8 gathered

          What to do, step by step

          1. 1

            Put your response deadline on the calendar

            Write down the deadline on the court papers and plan to respond well before it.

          2. 2

            Check the contractor's license

            Look up license or registration status on the contract date and during the work, using your state panel below.

          3. 3

            Read your contract closely

            Look for required terms, a cancellation notice, an arbitration clause and an attorney fee clause.

          4. 4

            Price your defenses and losses

            Get an independent estimate for defects and unfinished work, and total up your payments.

          5. 5

            Organize your evidence

            OwnersBack Dispute Prep can organize your records into a dated timeline, evidence index and a demand letter you send in your own name, which helps whether you settle or go to court.

          6. 6

            File your response and any counterclaim

            Answer or appear as the court requires, and raise your own claims in the same case.

          7. 7

            Consider a written settlement offer

            If you agree you owe part of the bill, a written offer for that amount, with dates, can end the case sooner.

          When to talk to a lawyer now

          • The amount claimed is above your state's small claims limit.
          • The contractor also filed a lien or is trying to foreclose on your home.
          • Licensing or contract defenses may apply and you need to know your state's rule.
          • You want to bring a consumer protection counterclaim.
          • You missed a deadline or a default judgment was entered.
          Find a lawyer in your state

          Turn this into a plan you can act on

          We turn your paperwork, photos and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index, a step-by-step plan and a demand letter. A person on our team checks every one.

          Hiring someone new to finish the job? Check their bid for free before you sign.

          Common follow-up questions

          What happens if I ignore the lawsuit?

          The court can enter a default judgment for the contractor, often for the full amount claimed, and the contractor can then try to collect it from you. Always respond by the deadline.

          Do I have to pay an unlicensed contractor who sues me?

          In some states, no. In Florida, for example, a contractor without the required state license cannot enforce the contract against you[5], and California's licensing board says an unlicensed contractor cannot use the courts to collect from you[7]. Other states allow some recovery.

          Can I sue the contractor back in the same case?

          Usually yes. A counterclaim for defective or unfinished work, or for consumer protection violations, is commonly raised in the same lawsuit. Small claims courts may limit how large a counterclaim can be.

          Is a missing contract term a complete defense?

          Sometimes, but not usually. In Connecticut it can bar the contractor's recovery unless you acted in bad faith[10], while Pennsylvania lets the contractor recover the reasonable value of its work[12].

          Can I recover my attorney fees if I win?

          Only if a contract or statute allows it. Some lien statutes and consumer protection laws do, and some contracts have fee clauses that can apply to either side.

          What if the contractor is suing me over an online review?

          Different defenses apply, so read what to do when a contractor threatens you over a review and talk to a lawyer fast. In Texas, the anti-SLAPP law lets you ask the court to dismiss a suit based on your exercise of free speech, but the motion must be filed within 60 days after you are served[17]. If the suit is to collect a fee under a no-review clause, the FTC explains that a business cannot use a contract term that charges you a penalty or fee for reviewing it, though the business can still sue over a review it says is defamatory[18].

          Laws and cases on this page

          Each one was read on its source and checked on November 19, 2026.

          1. 1

            Statute · Federal

            Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 2

            What it says

            A written arbitration clause in a contract involving interstate commerce is valid and enforceable, so if your contractor's agreement has one, a court will usually send the dispute to arbitration instead of a trial. You can still challenge the clause on the same grounds that would undo any contract, such as fraud.

            Keep in mind: Whether a particular clause can be avoided depends on its wording and on how courts in your state apply general contract defenses. Read the clause for who pays fees and whether small claims court is allowed.

          2. 2

            Court decision · WI · Supreme Court of Wisconsin

            Plante v. Jacobs, 10 Wis. 2d 567, 103 N.W.2d 296 (1960)

            What it says

            A builder sued homeowners for the unpaid balance on a new house. The court held that 'substantial performance' of a house contract does not require perfection, so the builder could recover the contract price minus the owners' damages, and for a living-room wall built in the wrong place the owners' damages were measured by any drop in the home's value rather than the cost of moving the wall.

            Keep in mind: Wisconsin Supreme Court case, and the builder won. It turned on its facts: missing items such as kitchen cabinets and gutters were credited to the owners, while the wall, built more than a foot out of place, was found to cause no loss in market value, and the owners had not asked for it to be fixed during construction. Repair costs are generally allowed for defects that can be fixed without tearing out a substantial part of the finished work; where a fix would mean major demolition, the owner may get only the drop in value. If the contract makes every detail essential, a stricter standard may apply. Other states may differ.

          3. 3

            Court decision · NY · New York Court of Appeals

            Jacob & Youngs, Inc. v. Kent, 230 N.Y. 239 (1921)

            What it says

            A builder used pipe from a different maker than the contract named, through a subcontractor's oversight, and the owner refused to make the final payment. New York's highest court held that for a small, unintentional deviation like this, the owner's credit is the difference in the home's value, not the cost of tearing out and replacing the work.

            Keep in mind: New York case from 1921. The court stressed the default was trivial and not willful; a contractor who deliberately or seriously departs from the contract may be treated differently. Other states may apply different rules.

          4. 4

            Statute · AZ

            Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 32-1153

            What it says

            In Arizona, a contractor cannot sue in state court to collect for work that requires a license unless the contractor alleges and proves it was licensed both when the contract was made and when the claim arose.

            Keep in mind: This blocks the contractor's lawsuit; it does not by itself order a refund to the homeowner. Courts decide how it applies to particular facts.

          5. 5

            Statute · FL

            Fla. Stat. § 489.128

            What it says

            In Florida, a contractor who did not hold the state license the job required cannot enforce the contract against you in court. The unlicensed contractor also has no lien or bond claim for the work done under that contract.

            Keep in mind: Florida only. It blocks the unlicensed contractor from enforcing the contract; it does not by itself order a refund of what you already paid. Licensing status is generally judged as of the contract date, and work that needs no state license is not covered.

          6. 6

            Statute · WA

            Wash. Rev. Code § 18.27.080

            What it says

            In Washington, a contractor who had to be registered cannot sue to collect payment for work or for breach of contract unless they prove they were a properly registered contractor when they contracted for the work.

            Keep in mind: A court may not find 'substantial compliance' unless all three are true: the state had the required registration information on file, and the contractor kept a bond and insurance in force the whole time. The court must also consider how long the contractor was unregistered.

          7. 7

            Official guidance · CA

            CSLB, It Pays to Get Licensed (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 7031)

            What it says

            California's licensing board says Business and Professions Code section 7031 lets a customer get back all the money paid to an unlicensed contractor, and stops an unlicensed contractor from using the courts to collect money from the customer. The same board page says projects of $1,000 or more in combined labor and materials must be done by a licensed contractor.

            Keep in mind: The official California code site (leginfo.legislature.ca.gov) would not load when this was checked, so this entry relies on the licensing board's own page rather than the statute text. The page is a board flyer aimed at unlicensed workers, it does not give the exact statute wording, and the date is inferred from the form code. Courts allow narrow exceptions, such as 'substantial compliance' with licensing, and getting money back usually means filing a lawsuit.

          8. 8

            Court decision · CA · Supreme Court of California

            Lewis & Queen v. N. M. Ball Sons, 48 Cal. 2d 141 (1957)

            What it says

            California's Supreme Court held that a contractor without the required license could not use the courts to get paid, even if that seems harsh to the contractor. The court said judges may not use fairness arguments to get around section 7031.

            Keep in mind: An older California case between two contracting businesses over equipment rentals tied to a state road project, not a home job. It applies California's licensing statute, which has since been amended; other states have different rules.

          9. 9

            Court decision · CA · Supreme Court of California

            Hydrotech Systems, Ltd. v. Oasis Waterpark, 52 Cal. 3d 988 (1991)

            What it says

            California's Supreme Court held that a contractor without a California license cannot get around the licensing law's bar on suing for payment by calling its claim fraud. If the claim is really about being paid for unlicensed work, Business and Professions Code section 7031 blocks it.

            Keep in mind: California case involving a commercial waterpark and an out-of-state contractor. It applies California's licensing statute; other states have different licensing laws and may allow unlicensed contractors some recovery.

          10. 10

            Court decision · CT · Supreme Court of Connecticut

            Barrett Builders v. Miller, 215 Conn. 316, 576 A.2d 455 (1990)

            What it says

            A contractor installed kitchen cabinets and countertops under a written contract that left out key details and the required three-day cancellation notice, then sued the homeowner for the unpaid balance. The Connecticut Supreme Court held that a contract that does not meet the Home Improvement Act's requirements cannot be enforced against the homeowner, and the contractor cannot recover the value of its work through quasi-contract (unjust enrichment) either.

            Keep in mind: Connecticut case under Connecticut General Statutes section 20-429. Connecticut later recognized a bad faith exception (Habetz v. Condon, 1992), so a homeowner who acts dishonestly may still have to pay. Other states differ; some, such as Pennsylvania, let a contractor with a noncompliant contract recover the reasonable value of its work.

          11. 11

            Court decision · CT · Supreme Court of Connecticut

            Habetz v. Condon, 224 Conn. 231, 618 A.2d 501 (1992)

            What it says

            A homeowner paid most of a $103,000 addition contract that lacked the required cancellation notice, then used that defect to avoid paying the rest and for extra work the homeowner had requested. The Connecticut Supreme Court held that a homeowner who acts in bad faith cannot use the Home Improvement Act to escape paying, and it defined bad faith as more than carelessness: it involves a dishonest purpose.

            Keep in mind: Connecticut case. Whether a homeowner acted in bad faith depends on the facts and is decided by the trial court. Other states may differ.

          12. 12

            Court decision · PA · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

            Shafer Electric & Construction v. Mantia, 626 Pa. 258, 96 A.3d 989 (2014)

            What it says

            Homeowners hired a contractor to build a garage addition under a contract that met only three of the 13 requirements of Pennsylvania's Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that the contractor could still sue for the reasonable value of its work (quantum meruit), even though the noncompliant contract itself could not be enforced.

            Keep in mind: Pennsylvania case. It cuts against homeowners who hope a missing contract term means they owe nothing; other states (for example Connecticut, in Barrett Builders v. Miller) reach a different result.

          13. 13

            Statute · MA

            Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 93A, § 9

            What it says

            Under the Massachusetts consumer protection law, you must send a written demand for relief at least 30 days before suing over an unfair or deceptive practice. If you win you get your actual damages or $25, whichever is more, the court can award two to three times that amount for willful or knowing violations or a bad-faith refusal to settle, and you recover reasonable attorney fees.

            Keep in mind: Massachusetts only. The 30-day demand is not required for a counterclaim or cross-claim, or if the contractor has no place of business and keeps no assets in Massachusetts. If the contractor makes a reasonable written settlement offer within 30 days and you reject it, your recovery can be limited to that offer and fees after the rejection may not be recovered.

          14. 14

            Statute · TX

            Tex. Prop. Code § 27.004

            What it says

            Under the Texas Residential Construction Liability Act, you must send the contractor written notice of the defects by certified mail, return receipt requested, at least 60 days before suing. The contractor gets a chance to inspect within 35 days and may make a written settlement offer within 60 days of your notice.

            Keep in mind: Texas only, for residential construction defects. If you skip the notice or inspection steps, the case can be abated (paused). Notice is excused if you must sue sooner to beat the statute of limitations or are raising the defect as a counterclaim. If you reject a reasonable settlement offer, your recovery is capped at the value of the contractor's last offer plus costs and attorney fees incurred before you rejected it. The damages you can recover are limited to the items the statute lists, such as reasonable repair costs.

          15. 15

            Court decision · OK · Supreme Court of Oklahoma

            Sloan v. Owen, 1977 OK 239, 579 P.2d 812

            What it says

            Homeowners sued their remodeling contractor, and the contractor tried to foreclose a mechanic's lien on their home. The homeowners lost their own claim but beat the lien, and the Oklahoma Supreme Court held they were entitled to a reasonable attorney fee for defeating the lien foreclosure.

            Keep in mind: Oklahoma Supreme Court case applying an Oklahoma lien fee statute as it read in 1971. In most states each side pays its own lawyer unless a contract or statute says otherwise, and fee rules vary widely.

          16. 16

            Statute · TX

            Tex. Prop. Code § 53.156

            What it says

            In a Texas lawsuit to foreclose or remove a mechanic's lien, the court awards court costs and reasonable attorney fees as are equitable and just. On a residential construction contract, the court is not required to order the property owner to pay the contractor's fees.

            Keep in mind: Texas only, and only in lien suits. Fees are up to the court and must be equitable and just, so they are not guaranteed.

          17. 17

            Statute · TX

            Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.003 (Texas Citizens Participation Act)

            What it says

            Texas's anti-SLAPP law lets you file a motion asking the court to dismiss a lawsuit that is based on, or filed in response to, your exercise of free speech. The motion must be filed within 60 days after you are served with the lawsuit.

            Keep in mind: Texas only, and it applies once you are actually sued, not to a threat. The contractor can keep the case alive by showing clear and specific evidence of each element of its claim, so a review with false statements of fact may not be protected. Missing the 60-day deadline can cost you this defense; talk to a Texas lawyer quickly.

          18. 18

            Official guidance · Federal

            FTC business guidance: Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know

            What it says

            The FTC explains that the Consumer Review Fairness Act protects your right to share honest opinions about a business in any forum, including social media. A business cannot use a contract term that bars or restricts your review, charges you a penalty or fee for reviewing, or takes the rights to your review content. The FTC and state Attorneys General enforce it.

            Keep in mind: The Act targets contract terms in form contracts; it does not stop a contractor from suing over a review it says is defamatory. The FTC notes a business may still prohibit or remove reviews that are clearly false or misleading, libelous, harassing, or unrelated to its products or services, though an opinion the business simply disagrees with is unlikely to be clearly false or misleading.

          Legal information, not legal advice

          This page explains the law in general terms so you can understand your options. It isn't legal advice for your situation, and reading it doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and differ by state, and the facts of your case matter. OwnersBack isn't a law firm. Before you sue, sign a settlement, or miss a deadline, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

          Contractor Suing You for Payment? Your Defenses | OwnersBack