The short answer
Your odds: Often a good claimThey can file a lawsuit, but an honest review is usually on solid ground. Truthful statements of fact and honest opinions are generally protected, and a federal law voids clauses in take-it-or-leave-it contracts that ban or penalize reviews. The key condition: stick to facts you can prove and opinions clearly labeled as yours, because false statements of fact can support a defamation claim.
What to know
- Truth is generally a defense to defamation, so a review you can back up with documents is much safer.
- Opinions like 'I would not hire them again' are treated differently from false factual claims like 'they stole my money.'
- The Consumer Review Fairness Act voids review gag clauses in form contracts, though it does not give you a right to sue.
- Many states have anti-SLAPP laws that can end weak lawsuits over speech early, but they vary widely.
- A threatening letter is not a lawsuit; respond calmly and in writing, and fix anything you cannot prove.
On this page
- Can a contractor really sue you over a review?
- If your contract has a no-review clause
- Anti-SLAPP laws and other protections
- How to write a review that stays on solid ground
- When the threat is really about money
- Your state's rules, with sources
- What to gather
- What to do, step by step
- When to talk to a lawyer now
- Common follow-up questions
- Laws and cases on this page
The law, in detailTap a topic to open it.
Can a contractor really sue you over a review?
Anyone can file a lawsuit, so the honest answer is yes, a contractor can sue. The better question is whether the suit would succeed. A contractor suing over a review would usually bring a defamation claim, which generally requires a false statement of fact about the contractor, shared with others, that harmed its reputation. The exact elements, and how much fault the writer must have, vary by state.
That means two kinds of statements are usually on safe ground. True statements of fact, such as 'the job was supposed to finish in March and the crew stopped coming in February,' are generally protected because truth is a defense. Honest opinions, such as 'I was very unhappy and would not hire them again,' are generally protected because an opinion is not a fact that can be proven false. Trouble starts with statements presented as fact that you cannot prove, such as calling the contractor a thief or a criminal.
Federal law points the same way. The Consumer Review Fairness Act does not protect content that is defamatory, harassing or otherwise unlawful, and a business can still sue for defamation, libel or slander, so the safest review sticks to true facts and honest opinion[1]. The FTC's guidance for businesses says the law protects your ability to share honest opinions about a business in any forum, including social media, and that an opinion a business simply disagrees with is unlikely to count as clearly false or misleading[2].
If your contract has a no-review clause
Some contractors put clauses in their contracts that forbid negative reviews or charge a fee if you post one. Under the federal Consumer Review Fairness Act, a clause in a standard, take-it-or-leave-it contract is void if it bars or restricts you from reviewing the contractor's goods, services or conduct, charges you a penalty or fee for doing so, or makes you hand over intellectual property rights in your review[1]. Written, oral and photo reviews, including online ones, are covered.
There are limits. The law covers only form contracts you had no meaningful chance to negotiate. It does not give you a right to sue the contractor; it is enforced by the FTC and state attorneys general[1]. If a contractor tries to enforce a gag clause against you, you can point to the law in your reply and report the clause to your state attorney general. See filing a complaint with the attorney general.
- Void in a form contract: a ban on negative reviews.
- Void in a form contract: a fee or penalty for posting a review.
- Void in a form contract: a clause taking the rights to your review or photos.
- Not protected by this law: false statements of fact, or harassing content.
Anti-SLAPP laws and other protections
Many states have laws, often called anti-SLAPP laws, meant to stop lawsuits that target people for speaking out on matters of public interest. Where they apply, they can let a court dismiss a weak speech-based lawsuit early, and some let the person who was sued recover attorney fees. Whether a contractor review is covered, and how strong the protection is, differs a great deal from state to state, and some states have no such law. A local lawyer can usually tell you quickly whether yours applies.
Texas is a clear example. Its anti-SLAPP law, the Texas Citizens Participation Act, lets you file a motion asking the court to dismiss a lawsuit that is based on, or filed in response to, your exercise of free speech, and the motion must be filed within 60 days after you are served[3]. It applies once you are actually sued, not to a threat, and the contractor can keep the case alive by showing clear and specific evidence of each element of its claim, so a review with false statements of fact may not be protected. The Act has an exemption for suits against businesses that sell goods or services, but the law says that exemption does not stop it from covering suits over consumer opinions or reviews and ratings of businesses, so a suit over your review of a contractor can fall under it[4]. If the court dismisses the suit under the Act, it must order the contractor to pay your court costs and reasonable attorney's fees[5]. That cuts both ways: if the court finds your motion frivolous or filed only to delay, it can make you pay the contractor's costs and fees instead.
Florida's law is narrower. It bars lawsuits that lack merit and are filed mainly because someone exercised protected free speech on a public issue, lets the person sued ask for a fast hearing to end the case, and requires the court to award the winning side reasonable attorney fees and costs[6]. But the statute defines protected speech narrowly: statements made before a government body on an issue it is reviewing, or made in or in connection with works like a book, news report or broadcast. Whether a typical online review qualifies is not settled by the text, so ask a Florida lawyer before relying on it.
How you wrote the review matters too. Courts generally read the whole review in context. A review that tells a dated story, sticks to what you saw, and separates your feelings from the facts is much harder to attack than a one-line accusation.
How to write a review that stays on solid ground
If you have not posted yet, or you are thinking about editing what you posted, aim for a review that a stranger could check against your documents. Calm, specific reviews also tend to be more useful to other homeowners than angry ones. The FTC notes that a business may still prohibit or remove reviews that are clearly false or misleading, libelous or harassing, which is one more reason to stick to what you can show[2].
If the contractor responds publicly, keep any reply short and factual. Arguing back and forth online rarely helps and can create new statements for the contractor to complain about.
- Describe what happened, with dates, in plain words.
- Mention that you have documents, like the contract and photos, without posting private details.
- Label opinions as yours, with phrases like 'in my experience' or 'I felt.'
- Avoid words that claim a crime, like 'fraud' or 'thief,' unless a court or agency has found it.
- Leave out workers' names and anything about anyone's personal life.
- Update the review if the contractor fixes the problem.
When the threat is really about money
Sometimes a threat over a review is really about the money in dispute. A contractor may threaten to sue for defamation, demand a disputed balance and threaten a lien, all in the same message. Keep these separate. A lien has its own rules, and a contractor who knowingly inflates a lien to pressure you can take on its own risk: in Florida, a lien is fraudulent if the lienholder willfully exaggerated the amount or claimed work or materials not provided, a fraudulent lien is unenforceable, and the owner can sue for damages and attorney fees[7]. A minor mistake or a good-faith dispute over the amount does not make a lien fraudulent, and other states handle inflated liens their own way. See what to do when a contractor threatens a lien.
If the contractor actually sues you for payment, see your defenses when a contractor sues you. And if you have your own claim for bad work or a lost deposit, the review is not your remedy. A written demand letter and a complaint to the licensing board usually do more to get your money back.
Your state's rules, with sources
Pick your state to see the rules that matter here, each linked to its official source.
What to gather
Tick things off as you collect them. Your list stays on this device only.
What to do, step by step
- 1
Save everything before changing anything
A threat is not a lawsuit. Save a copy of your review and the threat, with dates, before you edit or delete anything.
- 2
Check every statement in your review
Mark each sentence as a fact you can prove, an opinion, or something you cannot back up. Fix or remove the last kind.
- 3
Read your contract
If it has a no-review or penalty clause and you had no real chance to negotiate it, the Consumer Review Fairness Act may make that clause void.
- 4
Reply in writing, briefly
Say that you stand by your truthful account and honest opinions, and keep the dispute about the job separate. OwnersBack Dispute Prep can organize your records into a dated timeline, evidence index and a demand letter you send in your own name for that underlying dispute.
- 5
Report a gag clause
If the contractor is trying to enforce a review ban or penalty, tell your state attorney general's consumer protection office.
- 6
Act fast if you are served
If you receive court papers, do not ignore them. Talk to a lawyer quickly about your defenses and any anti-SLAPP protection in your state. In Texas, for example, the motion to dismiss must be filed within 60 days after you are served[3].
When to talk to a lawyer now
- You were served with a lawsuit or got a formal demand from the contractor's lawyer.
- Your review accuses the contractor of a crime and you cannot prove it.
- The contractor is demanding money under a no-review or penalty clause.
- Your state may have an anti-SLAPP law with short deadlines to use it (in Texas, 60 days after you are served).
Turn this into a plan you can act on
We turn your paperwork, photos and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index, a step-by-step plan and a demand letter. A person on our team checks every one.
Hiring someone new to finish the job? Check their bid for free before you sign.
Common follow-up questions
Is it legal to leave a negative review of my contractor?
Generally yes, if it is truthful and your opinions are clearly opinions. A review that states false facts can lead to a defamation claim, so stick to what you can prove.
Can a contractor charge me a fee for a bad review?
Not under a form contract you could not negotiate. The Consumer Review Fairness Act voids clauses in those contracts that ban or penalize reviews[1].
Should I take my review down?
Not automatically. If every factual statement is true and the rest is opinion, many people keep it up. If it includes something you cannot prove, editing it promptly can lower your risk.
Can a contractor ask me to agree not to post reviews in exchange for a refund?
A settlement you actually negotiate is different from a form contract, and the Consumer Review Fairness Act covers only form contracts[1]. Read any settlement terms carefully before signing, and get advice if they limit what you can say.
What is an anti-SLAPP law?
It is a state law meant to stop lawsuits filed to punish people for speaking out on public issues. Where one applies, a court may dismiss the case early. Coverage and strength vary by state, and some states have none. Texas's law, for example, can cover suits over reviews of businesses[4], while Florida's covers a narrower set of speech and may not reach a typical online review[6].
Laws and cases on this page
Each one was read on its source and checked on November 19, 2026.
- 1
Statute · Federal
Consumer Review Fairness Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45b
What it says
A clause in a standard, take-it-or-leave-it contract is void if it bars or restricts you from reviewing the contractor's goods, services or conduct, charges you a penalty or fee for doing so, or makes you hand over intellectual property rights in your review. Written, oral and photo reviews, including online ones, and performance assessments are covered.
Keep in mind: Covers only form contracts you had no meaningful chance to negotiate, and not employment or independent contractor contracts. The law does not give you a right to sue; it is enforced by the FTC and state attorneys general. It does not protect content that is defamatory, harassing or otherwise unlawful, and a business can still sue for defamation, libel or slander, so stick to true facts and honest opinion.
- 2
Official guidance · Federal
FTC business guidance: Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know
What it says
The FTC explains that the Consumer Review Fairness Act protects your right to share honest opinions about a business in any forum, including social media. A business cannot use a contract term that bars or restricts your review, charges you a penalty or fee for reviewing, or takes the rights to your review content. The FTC and state Attorneys General enforce it.
Keep in mind: The Act targets contract terms in form contracts; it does not stop a contractor from suing over a review it says is defamatory. The FTC notes a business may still prohibit or remove reviews that are clearly false or misleading, libelous, harassing, or unrelated to its products or services, though an opinion the business simply disagrees with is unlikely to be clearly false or misleading.
- 3
Statute · TX
Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.003 (Texas Citizens Participation Act)
What it says
Texas's anti-SLAPP law lets you file a motion asking the court to dismiss a lawsuit that is based on, or filed in response to, your exercise of free speech. The motion must be filed within 60 days after you are served with the lawsuit.
Keep in mind: Texas only, and it applies once you are actually sued, not to a threat. The contractor can keep the case alive by showing clear and specific evidence of each element of its claim, so a review with false statements of fact may not be protected. Missing the 60-day deadline can cost you this defense; talk to a Texas lawyer quickly.
- 4
Statute · TX
Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.010(b)
What it says
The Texas Citizens Participation Act has an exemption for lawsuits against businesses selling goods or services, but the law says that exemption does not stop it from applying to lawsuits over consumer opinions, evaluations of consumer complaints, or reviews or ratings of businesses. So a suit over your online review of a contractor can fall under the Act.
Keep in mind: Texas only. Being covered by the Act does not mean the case is automatically dismissed; the court still weighs the contractor's evidence under § 27.005.
- 5
Statute · TX
Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.009
What it says
If a Texas court dismisses a lawsuit under the Texas Citizens Participation Act, it must order the party who sued you to pay your court costs and reasonable attorney's fees for defending the case.
Keep in mind: Texas only, and only when the court actually dismisses the suit under this chapter. If the court finds your motion to dismiss frivolous or filed only to delay, it can make you pay the other side's costs and fees instead.
- 6
Statute · FL
Fla. Stat. § 768.295 (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPP) prohibited)
What it says
Florida bars lawsuits that lack merit and are filed mainly because someone exercised protected free speech on a public issue. A person sued that way can ask for a fast hearing to end the case, and the court must award the winning side reasonable attorney fees and costs.
Keep in mind: Florida only. The statute defines protected speech narrowly: statements made before a government body on an issue it is reviewing, or made in or in connection with works like a book, news report, broadcast or similar work. Whether a typical online review qualifies is not settled by the text, so ask a Florida lawyer before relying on it.
- 7
Statute · FL
Fla. Stat. § 713.31
What it says
In Florida, a construction lien is fraudulent if the lienholder willfully exaggerated the amount, willfully claimed work or materials not provided, or was so grossly careless that it amounts to willful exaggeration. A fraudulent lien is unenforceable, the owner can sue for damages, attorney fees and possibly punitive damages, and willfully filing one is a third-degree felony.
Keep in mind: Florida law only. A minor mistake or a good-faith dispute over the amount owed does not make a lien fraudulent. Other states handle false or inflated liens through their own statutes or through slander of title claims.
Read next
Legal information, not legal advice
This page explains the law in general terms so you can understand your options. It isn't legal advice for your situation, and reading it doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and differ by state, and the facts of your case matter. OwnersBack isn't a law firm. Before you sue, sign a settlement, or miss a deadline, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.