Skip to content
OwnersBack
Sample only. The contractor, homeowner and proposal on this page are entirely fictional.

OwnersBack Review · Sample report

Kitchen remodel proposal review

Document reviewed
Kitchen Remodel Proposal #NG-2291
Contractor
Northgate Kitchen & Bath LLC (fictional)
Proposal amount
$45,000 · 3 pages
Review status
Human-reviewed & approved

Summary

This proposal covers the main parts of a kitchen remodel, but leaves several important questions open. The biggest items to resolve before signing are the 50% deposit, the undefined electrical scope, the lack of a written change-order process, and the absence of any mention of permits. None of these mean the contractor is acting in bad faith. They're gaps worth closing in writing before money changes hands.

High priority

4

Medium priority

8

Low priority

1

What each label means

  • Not foundThe topic does not appear anywhere in the document we reviewed.
  • UnclearThe topic is mentioned, but the wording is vague or open to more than one reading.
  • Potential concernThe term is stated clearly, but it may increase your financial or scheduling exposure. Worth discussing before you sign.

How we set priority

  • High priorityRaise this before you sign or make a payment.
  • Medium priorityGet this clarified in writing before work begins.
  • Low priorityGood to confirm, but unlikely to change your decision on its own.

An item marked “Not found” or “Unclear” isn’t necessarily a problem. It’s something to ask about, not a legal violation or defect.

Raise before you sign or pay (4)

F1Potential concernHigh priorityPayments

Half the contract price is due at signing

Source: Proposal §5, page 2

“50% deposit due upon signing ($22,500).”

You would pay $22,500 before any work or materials arrive. A large up-front deposit increases how much money is at risk if the project is delayed or the relationship breaks down. Some states limit how much a home-improvement contractor may collect up front, so the allowed amount depends on where you live.

Ask your contractor

“What does the deposit cover, and would you accept a smaller deposit with payments tied to completed stages of work?”

Recommended next step

Check your state's contractor licensing agency for any deposit limits before agreeing to this amount.

F2UnclearHigh priorityScope

"Electrical updates as needed" has no defined scope

Source: Proposal §2.5, page 1

“2.5 Electrical updates as needed.”

There are no quantities, locations or fixture counts. It isn't clear whether new circuits, outlets, under-cabinet lighting or panel work are included in the $45,000, or would be billed later as extras.

Ask your contractor

“Can you list the specific electrical work included, such as the number of new outlets, circuits and light locations, and what would count as extra?”

Recommended next step

Ask for an itemized electrical scope in writing before signing.

F3Potential concernHigh priorityPayments

Change-order process is not defined

Source: Proposal §7, page 3

“Any changes requested by homeowner will be billed accordingly.”

The proposal doesn't say changes must be written, priced, and approved by you before the work is done. Without that, extra charges can appear on an invoice after the fact, which is a common source of disputes.

Ask your contractor

“Will every change be documented in a written change order showing the price and schedule impact, signed by both of us before work starts?”

Recommended next step

Request that a written change-order procedure be added to the contract.

F4Not foundHigh priorityOversight

Permits and inspections are not mentioned

Source: Not found in the document reviewed

We did not find any reference to permits or inspections. Kitchen remodels that involve electrical or plumbing work often require permits, depending on your local building department. The document doesn't say who applies, who pays, or whether inspections happen before walls are closed.

Ask your contractor

“Which permits will this project need, who will pull them, and is the permit cost included in the price?”

Recommended next step

Confirm requirements with your city or county building department.

Clarify in writing before work begins (8)

F5UnclearMedium priorityPayments

90% is paid once cabinets are installed

Source: Proposal §5, page 2

“40% due upon cabinet installation ($18,000).”

After cabinet installation you will have paid $40,500 of $45,000, while countertops, flooring, plumbing reconnection, painting and possibly electrical work may still remain. The milestone also doesn't define what "installation" means (set in place? fully finished with hardware?).

Ask your contractor

“Could we add milestones for countertops and flooring so payments track more closely to completed work?”

Recommended next step

Propose a payment schedule with more milestones, each tied to clearly described completed work.

F6Potential concernMedium priorityPayments

Cabinet allowance may not match your selections

Source: Proposal §3, page 2

“Cabinets: $9,500 allowance.”

Allowances are placeholders. If the cabinets you choose cost more, you pay the difference. The proposal doesn't say whether the $9,500 covers installation labor and hardware, or whether the contractor adds a markup to overages.

Ask your contractor

“Does the $9,500 allowance include installation and hardware, and how are overages or unused amounts handled?”

Recommended next step

Price your preferred cabinets before signing to see if the allowance is realistic.

F7UnclearMedium priorityScope

Countertop and flooring materials aren't specified

Source: Proposal §2.3–2.4, page 1

“2.3 Furnish and install quartz countertops. 2.4 Install new LVP flooring in kitchen area.”

There's no brand, color, thickness, edge profile, or square footage for the quartz, and no product, wear-layer or square footage for the flooring. Two contractors could deliver very different results under the same wording.

Ask your contractor

“Can you add the specific products, quantities and square footage for countertops and flooring?”

Recommended next step

Ask that selected materials be written into the contract or an attached selections sheet.

F8UnclearMedium priorityTimeline

No completion date or delay terms

Source: Proposal §6, page 2

“Work to begin approximately 2–3 weeks after signing. Estimated duration 6–8 weeks.”

Both the start and the duration are approximate, and the document doesn't say what happens if the project runs long, how delays will be communicated, or how material back-orders are handled.

Ask your contractor

“Can we add a target start and completion date, plus how you'll notify me of delays and why they occurred?”

Recommended next step

Ask for a written schedule with key milestones, such as demolition, rough-in, cabinets, counters and final.

F9Not foundMedium priorityOversight

License and insurance details are not included

Source: Not found in the document reviewed

We did not find a contractor license number or proof of insurance anywhere in the proposal. OwnersBack has not verified this contractor's license or insurance.

Ask your contractor

“What is your contractor license number, and can you send a current certificate of liability insurance?”

Recommended next step

Look up the license number on your state's official contractor licensing website.

F10UnclearMedium priorityWarranty & completion

Warranty has no length or coverage details

Source: Proposal §8, page 3

“Contractor warrants all workmanship.”

The warranty doesn't state how long it lasts, what it covers, how to make a claim, or how manufacturer warranties on cabinets, counters and flooring are passed on to you.

Ask your contractor

“How long is your workmanship warranty, what does it cover, and how do I request warranty repairs?”

Recommended next step

Request warranty terms in writing, including duration and the claim process.

F11UnclearMedium priorityWarranty & completion

"Completion" isn't defined before final payment

Source: Proposal §5, page 2

“10% due upon completion ($4,500).”

There's no mention of a final walkthrough, a punch list for unfinished items, or any final inspection before the last payment is due.

Ask your contractor

“Can final payment be due after a joint walkthrough, completion of the punch list, and any required final inspection?”

Recommended next step

Add a written definition of completion to the payment terms.

F12Not foundMedium priorityOversight

Lien releases are not mentioned

Source: Not found in the document reviewed

We did not find any mention of lien releases or waivers. In many states, unpaid subcontractors or suppliers may be able to file a lien against the property even after the homeowner has paid the general contractor. Rules vary by state.

Ask your contractor

“Will you provide lien releases from yourself and major subcontractors or suppliers as payments are made?”

Recommended next step

Ask a local attorney or your state's consumer resources how lien rules apply where you live.

Good to confirm (1)

F13Not foundLow priorityScope

Debris removal isn't addressed

Source: Not found in the document reviewed

§9 covers keeping the site "broom clean," but we did not find any mention of hauling away demolition debris, dumpster placement, or disposal costs.

Ask your contractor

“Is debris haul-away and disposal included in the price, and where would a dumpster be placed?”

Recommended next step

Confirm in writing who removes and pays for demolition debris.

Contractor clarification checklist

Copy these into an email to your contractor, and keep their written answers with your contract.

  1. 1What does the deposit cover, and would you accept a smaller deposit with payments tied to completed stages of work? F1
  2. 2Can you list the specific electrical work included, such as the number of new outlets, circuits and light locations, and what would count as extra? F2
  3. 3Will every change be documented in a written change order showing the price and schedule impact, signed by both of us before work starts? F3
  4. 4Which permits will this project need, who will pull them, and is the permit cost included in the price? F4
  5. 5Could we add milestones for countertops and flooring so payments track more closely to completed work? F5
  6. 6Does the $9,500 allowance include installation and hardware, and how are overages or unused amounts handled? F6
  7. 7Can you add the specific products, quantities and square footage for countertops and flooring? F7
  8. 8Can we add a target start and completion date, plus how you'll notify me of delays and why they occurred? F8
  9. 9What is your contractor license number, and can you send a current certificate of liability insurance? F9
  10. 10How long is your workmanship warranty, what does it cover, and how do I request warranty repairs? F10
  11. 11Can final payment be due after a joint walkthrough, completion of the punch list, and any required final inspection? F11
  12. 12Will you provide lien releases from yourself and major subcontractors or suppliers as payments are made? F12
  13. 13Is debris haul-away and disposal included in the price, and where would a dumpster be placed? F13

About this report

This report is an educational review of the document provided. It is not legal advice, a property inspection, an engineering assessment, or a certification of code compliance. OwnersBack has not verified the contractor's license, insurance or permits. Requirements vary by state and local jurisdiction. For legal questions, consult a licensed attorney in your state. A real report is delivered as a secure web page and a downloadable PDF.

Want this for your own project?

Upload your estimate, proposal or contract and get a personally reviewed report like this one.