Skip to content
OwnersBack

The OwnersBack Checklist

37 ways a renovation goes sideways.

We started with everything that went wrong on our own renovation, then added what state contractor boards and the FTC tell homeowners to watch for. Every OwnersBack report checks your documents against every item on this list, and marks each one covered, unclear, missing or worth asking about.

Who you're hiring

Before anything else: is the business on the paper the business you think it is?

  1. #L1

    License or registration number is on the contract

    We look for: The contractor's state license or registration number appears in the document and matches the business name.

    Several states require it on the contract. Without it you can't look the contractor up, and some protections only apply to licensed contractors.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; Oregon CCB, Contractor Tools (required terms and notices)

  2. #L2

    Name, address and phone match the state record

    We look for: The legal business name and a street address (not only a P.O. box) are listed.

    If something goes wrong, notices and complaints go to the address of record. A mismatch is worth asking about.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; Oregon CCB, Contractor Tools (required terms and notices)

  3. #L3

    Insurance is stated, not assumed

    We look for: The document mentions liability insurance and workers' compensation, or says a certificate will be provided.

    If a worker is hurt or your house is damaged, uninsured work can land on you.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; Washington L&I, Hire Smart Step by Step

  4. #L4

    Bond or recovery-fund coverage is known

    We look for: Whether the contractor holds a state bond, and whether your state has a recovery fund.

    In several states the bond or fund is the main way to recover money when a contractor won't fix or finish the job.

    From: Washington L&I, Hire Smart Step by Step

  5. #L5

    Subcontractors are named or at least disclosed

    We look for: Whether trades like electrical or plumbing are subcontracted and to whom.

    Unpaid subcontractors and suppliers can lien your property even if you paid the general contractor.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

What's actually included

Most surprise bills start with a sentence that sounded fine when you signed it.

  1. #S1

    Scope is specific enough to check

    We look for: Each line of work says what, how many and where: fixture counts, square footage, outlet and circuit counts.

    "As needed" and "per discussions" can't be held to anything. Whatever isn't written becomes an extra later.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; Our own renovation

  2. #S2

    Materials are named by brand, model or grade

    We look for: Cabinets, counters, flooring, fixtures and roofing are identified closely enough to verify on delivery.

    "Quartz countertops" covers a wide price range. A substitution is hard to dispute if nothing was specified.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  3. #S3

    Allowances say what they include

    We look for: Each allowance states whether it covers installation, tax and delivery, and what happens if you go over.

    An allowance that's too low for what you want turns into an overage you hadn't budgeted.

    From: Our own renovation

  4. #S4

    Exclusions are listed

    We look for: The document says what is not included: haul-away, patching, painting, appliance hookup, landscaping repair.

    Comparing two bids is meaningless if one quietly excludes half the work.

    From: Our own renovation

  5. #S5

    Hidden-condition terms are written down

    We look for: What happens if they open a wall or floor and find rot, mold, bad wiring or structural problems: who decides, how it's priced, whether work stops.

    When walls open up, nobody can know in advance what's behind them. What you can control is having the process in writing before it happens.

    From: Our own renovation

  6. #S6

    Demolition, cleanup and debris are covered

    We look for: Who removes debris, daily cleanup expectations and final cleaning.

    A common source of friction at the end of a job, and a common line item that appears late.

    From: Our own renovation

  7. #S7

    Design goal matches the written scope

    We look for: When inspiration photos are provided, the written scope and materials can actually produce that result.

    The picture in your head isn't part of the contract. Only the words are.

    From: Our own renovation

  8. #S8

    Bids are comparable line for line

    We look for: When there are multiple bids, the same items are present in each, or the differences are called out.

    The cheapest bid is often cheapest because something is missing from it.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

How the money moves

Payments that run ahead of the work are the single biggest risk you control.

  1. #P1

    Deposit is within your state's limit

    We look for: The deposit amount compared to your state's rule, if your state has one.

    Some states cap deposits on home improvement work. California, for example, caps it at $1,000 or 10%, whichever is less.

    From: California CSLB, What Should I Look for in a Contract

  2. #P2

    Payments are tied to finished work

    We look for: Each payment is due when a defined, checkable stage is complete, not on dates or "progress".

    If work falls behind, payments should fall behind with it.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; California CSLB, Construction Checklist

  3. #P3

    Payments don't get ahead of the work

    We look for: Total paid at each milestone compared with the share of work done at that point.

    Once you've paid for work that isn't done, your leverage is gone.

    From: California CSLB, Construction Checklist

  4. #P4

    A final payment is held until completion

    We look for: A meaningful final payment is due only after a walkthrough, punch list and any final inspection.

    The last payment is what gets the punch list finished.

    From: NASCLA, Home Improvement Consumer Guide; Washington L&I, Hire Smart Step by Step

  5. #P5

    Lien releases come with payments

    We look for: Whether the contract provides lien releases or waivers from the contractor, subcontractors and suppliers as you pay.

    Without them you can end up paying twice for the same materials or labor.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  6. #P6

    Total price and what changes it are clear

    We look for: One total, plus a list of what can change it (allowances, unit prices, hidden conditions).

    "Estimate" versus "contract price" matters. Know which one you're signing.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  7. #P7

    Invoices match the contract

    We look for: Each invoice line traced back to the contract, an approved change order, or nothing.

    Charges with no contract or change order behind them are the first thing to question.

    From: Our own renovation

When plans change

Every project changes. The question is whether the paperwork changes with it.

  1. #C1

    Change orders must be written and signed

    We look for: The contract requires a written, signed change order before extra work starts.

    Verbal changes are where most invoice disputes begin.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; California CSLB, Construction Checklist

  2. #C2

    Change orders state price and schedule impact

    We look for: Each change order shows the added cost and any change to the completion date.

    A change with no price is a blank check. A change with no date resets the schedule silently.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  3. #C3

    Pricing for extras is defined

    We look for: Hourly rates, markup on materials or unit prices for extra work.

    Without them, every extra is a negotiation after the fact.

    From: Our own renovation

Time

"Approximately" is not a schedule.

  1. #T1

    Start and completion dates are stated

    We look for: An estimated start date and completion date, or a duration from a defined start.

    Without dates there's no way to say the job is late.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  2. #T2

    Allowed delays are defined

    We look for: What counts as an excusable delay (weather, permits, material shortages) and how you'll be told.

    Separates real delays from a contractor who's working another job.

    From: California CSLB, What Should I Look for in a Contract

  3. #T3

    Communication plan exists

    We look for: Who your point of contact is and how often you'll get updates.

    Most disputes get worse during the silence before them.

    From: Our own renovation

Permits, notices and your rights

Some of this is required by your state. We check your documents against your state's rules where we have them.

  1. #R1

    Permit responsibility is assigned

    We look for: Who pulls permits, who pays for them and who schedules inspections.

    If the contractor skips a required permit, the problem can stay with the house, and with you.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  2. #R2

    Required state notices are included

    We look for: Your state's required notices, compared against what's attached to the contract.

    Missing notices can affect your rights, and sometimes the contractor's. We list what your state requires.

    From: Oregon CCB, Contractor Tools (required terms and notices); California CSLB, What Should I Look for in a Contract

  3. #R3

    Right-to-cancel notice is present

    We look for: Whether your state gives you a cancellation window and whether the contract says so.

    If you have a right to cancel, you should know how long it lasts before work starts.

    From: Oregon CCB, Contractor Tools (required terms and notices); California CSLB, What Should I Look for in a Contract

  4. #R4

    Dispute terms are understood

    We look for: Arbitration, mediation, attorney-fee or venue clauses, and what they mean for your options.

    These clauses decide where and how a disagreement gets resolved. Worth having an attorney read if they're there.

    From: Oregon CCB, Contractor Tools (required terms and notices)

After it's done

Warranty and closeout are where a finished job becomes a finished job.

  1. #W1

    Workmanship warranty has a length and a scope

    We look for: How long the warranty lasts, what it covers and how you make a claim.

    "Contractor warrants all workmanship" has no end date and no process.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor

  2. #W2

    Manufacturer warranties are passed to you

    We look for: Whether product warranties and registration paperwork are handed over.

    Some product warranties need registration or installer certification to be valid.

    From: Our own renovation

  3. #W3

    "Complete" is defined

    We look for: A walkthrough, written punch list and sign-off before the job counts as finished.

    If "done" isn't defined, the final payment is due whenever they say it is.

    From: Our own renovation

Your record

If it goes wrong, the side with the better record has the stronger position.

  1. #D1

    Every agreement is in writing

    We look for: Promises made in conversation or by text that aren't in the contract.

    If it was promised but not written, ask for it in writing now.

    From: FTC, Hiring a Contractor; California CSLB, What Should I Look for in a Contract

  2. #D2

    Photos are dated and tied to stages

    We look for: Before, during and after photos, linked to the contract item each one shows.

    Photos with dates and context are the strongest evidence a homeowner has.

    From: Our own renovation

  3. #D3

    A timeline of what happened exists

    We look for: Dates of signing, payments, change orders, delays, problems and conversations.

    Complaint processes and attorneys both start by asking for a timeline.

    From: Our own renovation

  4. #D4

    Pre-complaint steps are known

    We look for: Whether your state requires written notice to the contractor before a complaint, and how it must be sent.

    In Oregon, for example, residential complaints require written notice by certified mail first.

    From: Oregon CCB, Property Owner Complaint Form

Want us to check yours?

Upload your contract, estimates and photos. We check every item above against your documents and your state's rules, and a person reviews every finding before you see it.

General information, not legal advice. State rules vary and change. Follow the linked sources for the current rule.