Skip to content
OwnersBack

Bad work and damage

Who pays for structural or foundation defects a contractor caused?

The short answer

Your odds: Depends on the facts

It depends, but if the contractor's work caused the problem, the contractor or builder is usually the one who should pay. These claims can be strong when the cause is clear, but they are hard in practice: you will likely need an engineer to prove the cause, many states require written notice before you sue, and deadlines matter. Soil movement, design by others or normal settling can also shift the blame.

Steps to take
7
Laws and cases cited
12
Last checked

What to know

  • A contractor or builder whose work caused structural damage can be liable for the cost to repair it.
  • You usually need an engineer or similar expert to prove what caused the problem.
  • Written warranties can control, so read yours before you rely on broader implied promises.
  • Many states require written notice and a chance to inspect before you sue over defects.
  • Filing deadlines can run from completion or discovery, so act quickly once you see signs.
On this page
  1. Do you have a case?
  2. The legal claims that usually apply
  3. What courts have said
  4. How it works in your state
  5. What it costs and how long it takes
  6. Your state's rules, with sources
  7. What to gather
  8. What to do, step by step
  9. When to talk to a lawyer now
  10. Common follow-up questions
  11. Laws and cases on this page

The law, in detailTap a topic to open it.

Do you have a case?

Structural and foundation claims turn on cause. You generally need to show that there is a real defect (not just cosmetic cracks), that it came from the contractor's or builder's work rather than something else, and that you acted within your state's deadlines. Warning signs include doors and windows that stick, widening cracks in walls or slabs, sloping floors, sagging beams and water getting in where it did not before.

The contractor may blame soil movement, drainage, weather, a design by an engineer or architect you hired, or normal settling. Some of those defenses are real. That is why an independent engineer's report is usually the most important piece of evidence in these cases. Our page on whether you need an expert to prove construction defects explains when and how to get one.

Who you can pursue depends on who did what: the general contractor or builder, a foundation repair company, a framing or concrete subcontractor, or a design professional. Your contract with each one matters. If several companies touched the work, list who did each part and when; that list often decides who ends up paying. If the cracks started when someone dug next door, the excavation may be the cause. In New York City, the state's highest court held that a former city excavation rule made those whose excavation damaged a neighboring building absolutely liable, so the damaged owner did not have to prove negligence[1]. That case involved a landmark commercial building in Manhattan and a code section repealed effective July 1, 2008, and the court did not decide the rule that replaced it, so ask a New York lawyer what applies now, and see damage from a neighbor's contractor.

What courts have said

In the Texas case that rejected buyer beware for new homes, a buyer's new house partly burned the first time a fire was lit in its badly built fireplace and chimney[2]. The court held the builder impliedly warranted that the home was built in a workmanlike manner and was fit to live in. That case is from 1968, Texas law has developed since, and other states may differ, though Iowa's Supreme Court reached a similar result for a builder-vendor of a new home[3].

A later Texas case shows the risk on the other side. A homeowner hired a company to repair a foundation under a contract with a written lifetime warranty. The Texas Supreme Court held that when the contract itself describes how the work will be done or its quality, those written terms control over the implied warranty[8]. The homeowner recovered nothing, because the jury found no breach of the written warranty and the remaining claim was filed too late.

Together, these cases show the two things that decide most foundation claims: what your contract and warranty actually say, and whether you acted in time.

How it works in your state

Many states require written notice and a chance to inspect before a defect lawsuit. In Texas, you must send written notice by certified mail at least 60 days before suing, and the contractor may inspect and make a written offer[9]. In Florida, you must serve a written notice of claim at least 60 days before filing, and the contractor has 45 days to respond[10]. In Colorado, you must send a written notice of claim at least 75 days before filing[11]. Under New York's new-home warranty, you must give the builder written notice no later than 30 days after the warranty period ends and let the builder inspect and repair[5]. Our page on notice-and-repair laws covers these steps.

Deadlines vary by state and can run from when the work was finished or from when you discovered the problem. Foundation problems often show up slowly, so see defects found years later if yours appeared well after the job.

Pick your state below to see your licensing board, any homeowner recovery fund and your small claims limit.

What it costs and how long it takes

Structural cases are more expensive than most contractor disputes. Expect to pay for an engineer's inspection and report, and possibly for testing. Repairs themselves can be large, which often puts these claims above small claims limits and into regular civil court, where a lawyer helps.

What you can recover is usually the reasonable cost of repair. Where a fix would mean tearing out a substantial part of the finished home, some courts award only the drop in the home's value instead; a Wisconsin court explained that line in a case about a new house[12]. With structural defects that affect safety, repair cost may be easier to justify, but this depends on the facts and your state.

Notice periods, inspections and expert work take time. Many structural claims settle once both sides' engineers have weighed in.

Your state's rules, with sources

Pick your state to see the rules that matter here, each linked to its official source.

What to gather

Tick things off as you collect them. Your list stays on this device only.

0 of 8 gathered

What to do, step by step

  1. 1

    Document and monitor the signs

    Photograph and measure cracks and gaps, mark their ends with a pencil and date, and repeat every few weeks. Progress over time is strong evidence.

  2. 2

    Hire an independent engineer

    Get a structural engineer, not the contractor, to inspect and write a report on the cause and the fix.

  3. 3

    Read your contract and warranty

    Check what was promised, any warranty limits and any notice or dispute steps. Note every deadline.

  4. 4

    Give written notice the right way

    Send the contractor or builder written notice of each defect, following your state's notice-and-repair law if it has one. OwnersBack Dispute Prep can organize your photos, reports and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index and a notice or demand letter you send in your own name.

  5. 5

    Allow inspection and weigh any offer

    Let the contractor inspect if the law requires it, and get any repair or cash offer in writing. Have your engineer review it.

  6. 6

    Take steps to prevent more damage

    Fix obvious drainage problems or water entry with reasonable temporary measures, and keep receipts.

  7. 7

    Talk to a lawyer before filing

    Given the cost and deadlines, get advice from a construction lawyer in your state before suing.

When to talk to a lawyer now

  • An engineer says the home has a structural defect affecting safety.
  • The repair cost is large or above your state's small claims limit.
  • The contractor or builder blames soil, design or another company.
  • You bought a new home from a builder and your state has a detailed defect law.
  • Your filing deadline may be close, or you are not sure when it started.
Find a lawyer in your state

Turn this into a plan you can act on

We turn your paperwork, photos and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index, a step-by-step plan and a demand letter. A person on our team checks every one.

Hiring someone new to finish the job? Check their bid for free before you sign.

Common follow-up questions

Is some foundation cracking normal?

Small hairline cracks can come from normal curing and settling. Cracks that widen, run diagonally from door or window corners, or come with sticking doors and sloping floors are more concerning. An engineer can tell the difference.

Does homeowners insurance cover foundation problems?

Many policies exclude settling, poor workmanship and earth movement, though they may cover sudden damage that results. Read your policy and ask your insurer. See whether homeowners insurance covers contractor damage.

My foundation repair company gave a lifetime warranty. Am I covered?

Read it closely. In Texas, the written terms of a foundation repair warranty controlled over the broader implied warranty, and the homeowner recovered nothing, because the jury found no breach of the written warranty and the remaining claim was filed too late[8]. Lifetime warranties often have conditions, such as maintenance or transfer rules.

How long do I have to sue?

It varies by state and claim, and some states have outer limits that run from completion no matter when you found the problem. See how long you have to sue your contractor and talk to a lawyer soon if the deadline may be close.

Laws and cases on this page

Each one was read on its source and checked on November 19, 2026.

  1. 1

    Court decision · NY · New York Court of Appeals

    Yenem Corp. v. 281 Broadway Holdings, 18 N.Y.3d 481 (2012)

    What it says

    New York's highest court held that the New York City excavation rule in former Administrative Code § 27-1031(b)(1) makes those whose excavation damages a neighboring building absolutely liable, so the damaged owner did not have to prove negligence and won summary judgment.

    Keep in mind: This applies only in New York City and to the former code section, which was repealed effective July 1, 2008; the court did not decide the replacement provision. The damaged property was a landmark commercial building in Manhattan.

  2. 2

    Court decision · TX · Supreme Court of Texas

    Humber v. Morton, 426 S.W.2d 554 (Tex. 1968)

    What it says

    A buyer's new house partly burned the first time a fire was lit in its badly built fireplace and chimney. The Texas Supreme Court rejected 'buyer beware' for new homes and held that a builder who sells a new house gives an implied warranty that it was built in a workmanlike manner and is suitable to live in.

    Keep in mind: Texas case from 1968 about a builder selling a new house, not a remodel. Texas law has developed since then, so check current Texas law. Other states may differ.

  3. 3

    Court decision · IA · Supreme Court of Iowa

    Kirk v. Ridgway, 373 N.W.2d 491 (Iowa 1985)

    What it says

    A buyer sued the contractor who built and sold the house to the buyer after the exterior paint peeled because it was incompatible with the building materials. The Iowa Supreme Court, noting that construction contracts already carry an implied warranty of workmanlike work, held that a builder-vendor of a home impliedly warrants it was built in a reasonably good and workmanlike manner and is reasonably fit for its purpose, and the buyer won.

    Keep in mind: Iowa case about the sale of a new house by the builder who built it. Other states may differ.

  4. 4

    Court decision · TX · Supreme Court of Texas

    Melody Home Manufacturing Co. v. Barnes, 741 S.W.2d 349 (Tex. 1987)

    What it says

    The Texas Supreme Court held that when someone is hired to repair or modify existing property, the law implies a promise that the work will be done in a 'good and workmanlike manner,' and consumers can sue for breach of it under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act. It defined good and workmanlike as the quality of work of someone with the needed knowledge, training or experience, done in a way people able to judge such work would consider proficient.

    Keep in mind: Texas case decided under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act. The opinion said this warranty may not be waived or disclaimed, but in Gonzales v. Southwest Olshan Foundation Repair Co. (2013) the Texas Supreme Court held it can be superseded when the contract itself spells out how the work will be done or its quality. Other states may differ.

  5. 5

    Statute · NY

    N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 777-a

    What it says

    When a builder sells a new home in New York, the law adds a warranty to the sale: one year for poor workmanship, two years for plumbing, electrical, heating, cooling and ventilation systems, and six years for material defects. You must give the builder written notice of the claim no later than 30 days after the warranty period ends and let them inspect and repair.

    Keep in mind: This covers the sale of a new home by a builder, not ordinary remodeling. Under § 777-b a builder can replace this implied warranty with a written limited warranty that meets the statute's standards, so read your purchase contract.

  6. 6

    Court decision · CA · Supreme Court of California

    Aas v. Superior Court, 24 Cal. 4th 627 (2000)

    What it says

    Homeowners sued their builder in negligence for construction defects that had not yet caused property damage or injury. California's Supreme Court held they could not recover in negligence for those defects alone, because the cost of fixing a defect that has not caused harm is purely economic loss.

    Keep in mind: California case about new-home construction. It barred only negligence (tort) claims for defects that had not caused damage; the homeowners' contract and warranty claims were not affected. It was later changed by statute in California: in McMillin Albany LLC v. Superior Court (2018), the California Supreme Court said the Right to Repair Act (Civil Code section 895 and following) effectively abrogated Aas for the new homes that Act covers. Other states treat this issue differently.

  7. 7

    Court decision · CA · Supreme Court of California

    McMillin Albany LLC v. Superior Court, 4 Cal. 5th 241 (2018)

    What it says

    California's Supreme Court held that the Right to Repair Act (Civil Code section 895 and following) is the main, nearly exclusive way to sue a builder over defects in a newly built home sold as a residence. Buyers must follow the Act's pre-lawsuit steps, which start with written notice to the builder and give it a chance to inspect and offer a repair, even if they only plead other claims.

    Keep in mind: California only, and only for original construction of homes intended to be sold as individual dwellings, so it generally does not reach a remodel by a contractor you hired (the court did not address remodels directly). The Act does not apply to claims for fraud, personal injury or violation of a statute. Many other states have their own notice-and-repair laws with different steps; some have none.

  8. 8

    Court decision · TX · Supreme Court of Texas

    Gonzales v. Southwest Olshan Foundation Repair Co., 400 S.W.3d 52 (Tex. 2013)

    What it says

    A homeowner hired a company to repair the home's foundation under a contract with a written lifetime warranty. The Texas Supreme Court held that the implied warranty of good and workmanlike repair only fills gaps: when the contract itself describes how the work will be done or its quality, the written terms control instead.

    Keep in mind: Texas case. The homeowner ended up recovering nothing because the jury found no breach of the express warranty and the remaining claim was filed too late. It shows why reading your written warranty and acting quickly matter. Other states may differ.

  9. 9

    Statute · TX

    Tex. Prop. Code § 27.004

    What it says

    Under the Texas Residential Construction Liability Act, you must send the contractor written notice of the defects by certified mail, return receipt requested, at least 60 days before suing. The contractor gets a chance to inspect within 35 days and may make a written settlement offer within 60 days of your notice.

    Keep in mind: Texas only, for residential construction defects. If you skip the notice or inspection steps, the case can be abated (paused). Notice is excused if you must sue sooner to beat the statute of limitations or are raising the defect as a counterclaim. If you reject a reasonable settlement offer, your recovery is capped at the value of the contractor's last offer plus costs and attorney fees incurred before you rejected it. The damages you can recover are limited to the items the statute lists, such as reasonable repair costs.

  10. 10

    Statute · FL

    Fla. Stat. § 558.004

    What it says

    Before suing a Florida contractor over construction defects, you must serve a written notice of claim at least 60 days before filing, describing each defect and where it is. The contractor then has 45 days to respond, for example with an offer to repair or pay.

    Keep in mind: Florida only, and only for construction defect claims. Larger condo or homeowner association claims have longer periods (120 days). If you sue without responding to a timely settlement offer, the court can pause your case.

  11. 11

    Statute · CO

    Colo. Rev. Stat. § 13-20-803.5

    What it says

    In Colorado, before you sue a contractor or builder over construction defects, you must send a written notice of claim at least 75 days before filing (90 days for commercial property), by certified mail with return receipt or by personal service. The law then sets a process for the contractor to inspect, and deadlines to respond (for example, a written offer within 30 days after the inspection ends, or 45 days for commercial property).

    Keep in mind: Cited from the 2025 signed bill (H.B. 25-1272) that amended this section and shows the notice language unchanged; the amendment applies to defect claims brought on or after its effective date. It applies to construction defect claims under Colorado's Construction Defect Action Reform Act.

  12. 12

    Court decision · WI · Supreme Court of Wisconsin

    Plante v. Jacobs, 10 Wis. 2d 567, 103 N.W.2d 296 (1960)

    What it says

    A builder sued homeowners for the unpaid balance on a new house. The court held that 'substantial performance' of a house contract does not require perfection, so the builder could recover the contract price minus the owners' damages, and for a living-room wall built in the wrong place the owners' damages were measured by any drop in the home's value rather than the cost of moving the wall.

    Keep in mind: Wisconsin Supreme Court case, and the builder won. It turned on its facts: missing items such as kitchen cabinets and gutters were credited to the owners, while the wall, built more than a foot out of place, was found to cause no loss in market value, and the owners had not asked for it to be fixed during construction. Repair costs are generally allowed for defects that can be fixed without tearing out a substantial part of the finished work; where a fix would mean major demolition, the owner may get only the drop in value. If the contract makes every detail essential, a stricter standard may apply. Other states may differ.

Legal information, not legal advice

This page explains the law in general terms so you can understand your options. It isn't legal advice for your situation, and reading it doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and differ by state, and the facts of your case matter. OwnersBack isn't a law firm. Before you sue, sign a settlement, or miss a deadline, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

Structural or Foundation Defects: Who Pays? | OwnersBack