Skip to content
OwnersBack

Suing and collecting

Can I sue the contractor personally if they have an LLC?

The short answer

Your odds: Depends on the facts

Sometimes, but not just because the business let you down. An LLC or corporation usually protects its owners from the company's debts, so your main claim is normally against the company. You may be able to reach the owner personally if they made false statements themselves, took part in deceptive conduct, misused money the law treats as held in trust, signed a personal guarantee, or ran the company as a sham.

Steps to take
6
Laws and cases cited
7
Last checked

What to know

  • Your contract is usually with the company, so the company is the main defendant.
  • Owners and officers can sometimes be personally liable for their own fraud or deceptive conduct, even without piercing the veil.
  • Some states treat construction payments as trust funds, and misusing them can create personal liability.
  • Piercing the corporate veil is possible but hard, and usually needs proof the company was a shell.
  • Check whether a real LLC ever existed; a sole proprietor is generally personally liable for business debts.
On this page
  1. Why the LLC usually protects the owner
  2. When owners can be personally liable
  3. When your payments are trust funds
  4. Piercing the corporate veil
  5. If the owner shuts down or files bankruptcy
  6. Your state's rules, with sources
  7. What to gather
  8. What to do, step by step
  9. When to talk to a lawyer now
  10. Common follow-up questions
  11. Laws and cases on this page

The law, in detailTap a topic to open it.

Why the LLC usually protects the owner

When you hire a contractor that operates as an LLC or corporation, your contract is usually with the company, not the person. The point of those business forms is to keep the owners' personal assets separate from the company's debts. So if the company breaks the contract, your breach of contract claim normally runs against the company, and a judgment against the company does not automatically reach the owner's house or bank account.

Before you assume there is an LLC, check. Look up the contractor's license and the state business registry, and read the name on your contract and on your canceled checks. If you contracted with a person, or with a business name that was never registered as a company, that person may be directly responsible. If the company was dissolved, or the name on the license does not match the contract, write that down. See how to check a contractor's license and history.

    When owners can be personally liable

    The most common route is the owner's own conduct. A person who commits fraud is generally responsible for it personally, even when acting for a company. Under consumer protection laws, some courts have gone further. Washington's Supreme Court held the president of a roofing company personally liable under the state Consumer Protection Act because he took part in the company's unfair and deceptive conduct, after the company took a payment, tore off part of a house and never finished; the court did not need to pierce the corporate veil[1]. The officer must have personally participated in or knowingly approved the wrongful conduct.

    The Texas Supreme Court held that a person who works for a company can be personally liable under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act for misrepresentations they make themselves, even when acting for the company[2]. That case involved new-home sales, not remodeling, and other states treat individual liability differently. The situations below are the ones that most often support a personal claim.

    • The owner personally made false statements to get you to sign or pay.
    • The owner personally took part in or approved deceptive conduct.
    • The owner signed a personal guarantee, or signed the contract in their own name.
    • The owner diverted money you paid for your job.
    • The company was a shell, with no real separation from the owner.

    When your payments are trust funds

    Some states treat money paid for a construction job as held in trust for the people who are owed for the work. In Texas, money paid to a contractor under a construction contract for improving real property is held in trust, and a contractor who intentionally or knowingly diverts it before paying what is owed to the people entitled to it misapplies trust funds, which is a crime at $500 or more; the property owner on a residential construction contract can be one of the beneficiaries[3]. Whether you can also recover money in a civil suit depends on the facts, and the statute lists defenses.

    These laws can matter in bankruptcy too. A federal bankruptcy appeals panel, applying Arizona's trust-fund law as it read in 1990, held that misusing trust money could be a fiduciary defalcation that bankruptcy does not erase, and that the officer who handled the money could be personally liable[4]. The claimant there was a subcontractor, the case was sent back for more fact-finding, and the U.S. Supreme Court later set a stricter standard for defalcation, so treat it as an example, not a rule. See when a contractor took money for materials.

      Piercing the corporate veil

      A court can ignore a company's separate existence and hold the owner responsible when the owner and the company are not really separate and letting the owner hide behind the company would be unfair. A leading California case lists the two things a court looks for, but in that case the court refused to disregard the corporation, so the claim lost[5]. Veil piercing is hard to win and depends on facts such as mixing personal and company money or using the company as an empty shell. Other states use similar but not identical tests.

      Courts do not always reach individuals even when the company clearly owes you. In a California case where homeowners recovered everything they paid a builder whose license had been suspended, the refund judgment ran only against the contractor's corporation, and the individuals who ran it were not held personally liable[6]. Signs that can support veil piercing are listed below.

      • Personal and company money mixed in the same accounts
      • A company that never had real assets or insurance to pay its debts
      • Company formalities ignored, such as no separate records
      • Money or assets moved out of the company once problems started

      If the owner shuts down or files bankruptcy

      Owners sometimes close one company and open another. The U.S. Supreme Court held that draining a company's money into other companies the owner controlled, so it could not pay a creditor, can count as actual fraud, so the resulting debt may survive the owner's personal bankruptcy even if the owner never told the creditor a lie[7]. The creditor still has to prove the fraud in bankruptcy court and meet the deadlines. See when a contractor reopens under a new name and how to collect a judgment.

        Your state's rules, with sources

        Pick your state to see the rules that matter here, each linked to its official source.

        What to gather

        Tick things off as you collect them. Your list stays on this device only.

        0 of 8 gathered

        What to do, step by step

        1. 1

          Identify exactly who you contracted with

          Compare the names on the contract, license, checks and business registry, and note any mismatch.

        2. 2

          List what the owner did personally

          Write down each statement, promise or handling of your money by the owner, with dates and proof.

        3. 3

          Trace your money

          Show where your payments went and whether suppliers and subcontractors were paid.

        4. 4

          Send a written demand

          Address it to the company and, where the facts support it, to the owner. OwnersBack Dispute Prep can organize your records into a dated timeline, evidence index and a demand letter you send in your own name.

        5. 5

          File the right complaints

          Report to the licensing board and, if money was diverted, consider a police report or an attorney general complaint.

        6. 6

          Talk to a lawyer before naming the owner in a suit

          Claims against individuals have higher stakes and more defenses, and a lawyer can tell you which theory fits your state.

        When to talk to a lawyer now

        • The owner personally made false statements, or took money for a purpose it was never used for.
        • The company closed, moved its assets or reopened under a new name.
        • The contractor or the owner filed bankruptcy.
        • Your loss is large and the company has no assets but the owner does.
        Find a lawyer in your state

        Turn this into a plan you can act on

        We turn your paperwork, photos and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index, a step-by-step plan and a demand letter. A person on our team checks every one.

        Hiring someone new to finish the job? Check their bid for free before you sign.

        Common follow-up questions

        Can I sue the owner of an LLC for breach of contract?

        Usually not, if the contract was with the LLC. The breach of contract claim normally runs against the company. Personal claims usually rest on the owner's own conduct, a personal guarantee, trust fund rules or veil piercing.

        What if the contractor never formed an LLC?

        Then the person who contracted with you may be personally responsible for the business's debts as a sole proprietor or partner. Check the state business registry and the name on your contract.

        Can I name both the company and the owner in small claims?

        You may be able to if you have a real basis for the owner's personal liability, but naming someone without one can backfire. Ask the clerk or a lawyer, and see small claims basics.

        Is misusing my payment a crime?

        It can be in some states. In Texas, intentionally or knowingly diverting construction trust funds is a Class A misdemeanor at $500 or more and a felony if done with intent to defraud[3]. Prosecutors decide whether to charge.

        Does the owner's bankruptcy wipe out my claim?

        Not always. Debts from actual fraud, including some asset-shifting schemes, may survive[7], but you must ask the bankruptcy court and meet strict deadlines.

        Laws and cases on this page

        Each one was read on its source and checked on November 19, 2026.

        1. 1

          Court decision · WA · Washington Supreme Court

          Grayson v. Nordic Construction Co., 92 Wn.2d 548, 599 P.2d 1271 (1979)

          What it says

          A roofing company took a payment, tore off part of a house, never finished, and later went bankrupt. The Washington Supreme Court held the company's president personally liable because he took part in the company's unfair and deceptive conduct under the state Consumer Protection Act, even though the court did not pierce the corporate veil.

          Keep in mind: Washington Supreme Court case under Washington's Consumer Protection Act. The officer must have personally participated in or knowingly approved the wrongful conduct. Other states have different rules on officer liability.

        2. 2

          Court decision · TX · Supreme Court of Texas

          Miller v. Keyser, 90 S.W.3d 712 (Tex. 2002)

          What it says

          A homebuilder's sales agent told buyers things about their lots that were not true. The Texas Supreme Court held that a person who works for a company can be personally liable under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act for misrepresentations he makes himself, even when acting for the company.

          Keep in mind: Texas Supreme Court case under the Texas DTPA, involving new-home sales rather than a remodeling contract. The court only decided that the agent could be held liable and sent the case back for further proceedings. It also noted that an agent who passes along false company information may seek indemnity from the employer. Other states' consumer laws may treat individual liability differently.

        3. 3

          Statute · TX

          Tex. Prop. Code §§ 162.001, 162.031 (Texas Construction Trust Fund Act)

          What it says

          In Texas, money paid to a contractor under a construction contract for improving Texas real property is held in trust. A contractor who intentionally or knowingly diverts that money before paying what is owed to the people entitled to it misapplies trust funds, which is a Class A misdemeanor at $500 or more and a third-degree felony if done with intent to defraud.

          Keep in mind: Texas only. Beneficiaries include people owed for labor and materials, and under § 162.003(b) the property owner on a residential construction contract. Criminal penalties are handled by prosecutors; whether you can also recover money in a civil suit depends on the facts. The statute lists defenses, such as using the money for the contractor's actual expenses directly related to the job, or paying what is owed within 30 days after written notice of a criminal complaint or investigation.

        4. 4

          Court decision · Federal · U.S. Bankruptcy Appellate Panel of the Ninth Circuit

          Woodworking Enterprises, Inc. v. Baird (In re Baird), 114 B.R. 198 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 1990)

          What it says

          A homeowner paid a contractor in full, but the contractor's company never paid the cabinet installer. The bankruptcy appeals court held that Arizona's construction trust-fund law made the money a trust, so misusing it could be a "defalcation" by a fiduciary that bankruptcy does not erase, and the officer who handled the money could be personally liable.

          Keep in mind: Federal bankruptcy appellate panel decision applying an Arizona statute (A.R.S. § 33-1005) as it read in 1990; the claimant here was a subcontractor, not the homeowner, and the case was sent back for more fact-finding rather than finally decided. The U.S. Supreme Court later held (Bullock v. BankChampaign, 2013) that a "defalcation" requires knowing or grossly reckless conduct, a stricter standard than this case used. Courts elsewhere, such as the Fifth Circuit for Texas, have reached different results under their state laws.

        5. 5

          Court decision · CA · California Court of Appeal, First District

          Associated Vendors, Inc. v. Oakland Meat Co., 210 Cal. App. 2d 825 (1962)

          What it says

          A court can ignore a company's separate existence and hold the owner personally responsible ("piercing the corporate veil" or "alter ego") when the owner and the company are not really separate and letting the owner hide behind the company would be unfair. This is a leading California case that lists the two things a court looks for.

          Keep in mind: California Court of Appeal case about a meat business, not a construction job. In this case the court affirmed the trial court's refusal to disregard the corporation, so the alter ego claim lost; the case is cited for the test, not as a win. Veil piercing is hard to win and depends on many facts, such as mixing personal and company money or using the company as a shell. Other states use similar but not identical tests.

        6. 6

          Court decision · CA · California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District

          White v. Cridlebaugh, 178 Cal. App. 4th 506 (2009)

          What it says

          Homeowners sued a builder whose license had been suspended because it no longer had a qualifying licensed individual. The court held that under California Business and Professions Code section 7031(b), the homeowners could recover everything they paid, and the contractor could not subtract the value of the work or materials it provided.

          Keep in mind: California appellate case applying a California statute. The refund judgment ran only against the contractor's corporation; the individuals who ran it were not held personally liable in this case. Section 7031(b) does not apply if the narrow 'substantial compliance' exception for licensing is met. Most states do not have a 'pay it all back' rule this strong; check your own state's law.

        7. 7

          Court decision · Federal · Supreme Court of the United States

          Husky International Electronics, Inc. v. Ritz, No. 15-145 (U.S. 2016)

          What it says

          A business owner drained his company's money into other companies he controlled so it could not pay a creditor. The U.S. Supreme Court held that this kind of asset-shifting scheme can count as "actual fraud," so the resulting debt may survive the owner's personal bankruptcy even if he never told the creditor a lie.

          Keep in mind: U.S. Supreme Court case under federal bankruptcy law; it applies nationwide but only decides what counts as "actual fraud." The Court reversed and sent the case back to the lower court; it did not decide whether this particular debt was "obtained by" the scheme and so survived bankruptcy. The creditor still has to prove the fraud in bankruptcy court and meet bankruptcy deadlines. The facts involved an electronics supplier, not a homeowner. The page shows the citation as 578 U.S. ___.

        Legal information, not legal advice

        This page explains the law in general terms so you can understand your options. It isn't legal advice for your situation, and reading it doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and differ by state, and the facts of your case matter. OwnersBack isn't a law firm. Before you sue, sign a settlement, or miss a deadline, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

        Can You Sue a Contractor Personally if It's an LLC? | OwnersBack