The short answer
Your odds: Depends on the factsA new company usually isn't responsible for the old one's debts just because the same person runs it, but you are not out of options. Your claim against the old business survives the name change, the owner may be personally liable in some situations, and money or equipment moved to dodge you can sometimes be pulled back. Report the new business to the licensing board right away, especially if it is working without a valid license.
What to know
- A new company is generally treated as a separate legal person, so a new name alone doesn't make it liable for the old debts.
- Courts recognize narrow exceptions, such as a new business that is a mere continuation of the old one or assets moved to escape debts.
- Fraudulent transfer laws can let you undo transfers made to keep money away from creditors.
- An owner who personally took part in deceptive conduct may be personally liable in some states.
- Report the new business to the licensing board, since reopening doesn't erase the license history.
On this page
The law, in detailTap a topic to open it.
Do you have a case?
Start by pinning down who you actually contracted with. If the old business was a sole proprietorship, the owner and the business were the same person, so the debt is the owner's debt, and a new business name doesn't change that. If the old business was an LLC or corporation, it is a separate legal person, and the owner is usually not personally on the hook for its debts. A simple trade name change by the same company also doesn't erase what that company owes.
The hard case is the one most homeowners face: the old LLC stops answering, and a new LLC with a different name shows up with the same owner, the same trucks and the same phone number. That overlap is a warning sign, but on its own it usually isn't enough to make the new company pay. You generally need to show something more, such as assets moved to escape debts, the old company being a sham, or the owner's own personal wrongdoing.
Your original claim doesn't disappear either way. You can still pursue the old company, and a judgment against it can open other doors, including a state recovery fund if the contractor was licensed when you hired them.
- Was the old business a sole proprietorship, an LLC or a corporation?
- Does the new business have the same owners, managers, address, phone, trucks or customers?
- Did equipment, vehicles, accounts or jobs move from the old company to the new one?
- When did the new business start compared with when your problem began?
- Does the new business hold a valid license, and in whose name?
The legal claims that usually apply
Successor liability is the first theory. Normally a company that buys or takes over another company's assets doesn't inherit its debts. California's Supreme Court restated the four traditional exceptions: the new company agreed to take on the debts, the deal was really a merger, the new company is a mere continuation of the old one, or the assets were moved to escape the old company's debts[1]. That case involved a defective ladder, not a contractor, and each state applies these exceptions its own way.
Fraudulent transfer is often the stronger theory. Florida law lets a creditor, including a homeowner with a claim or judgment, undo a transfer made with intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors. Courts look at warning signs such as transfers to insiders like relatives, transfers made after the debtor was sued or threatened with suit, transfers of nearly all assets, and hidden assets[2]. Most states have a similar law, but deadlines are short. In Florida, a claim based on actual intent generally must be brought within 4 years after the transfer or within 1 year after it was or reasonably could have been discovered.
Personal liability is the third. Piercing the corporate veil lets a court ignore the company and hold the owner responsible when the two aren't really separate and hiding behind the company would be unfair[3]. It is hard to win. A more direct route in some states is the owner's own conduct: Washington's Supreme Court held a roofing company's president personally liable under the state Consumer Protection Act because the president took part in the company's deceptive conduct, without piercing the veil[4].
What courts have said
Courts look at who owns the new business, not just whether the same kind of work continues. In Illinois, homeowners tried to hold an owner's son responsible after he took over the same heating business under the same name. The Illinois Supreme Court said no, because the mere continuation rule asks whether the same owners continue the same company[5]. That case involved a business passed on after the owner died, not a contractor who closed a company on purpose, but it shows that reopening under a relative's name doesn't automatically make the new business liable.
The U.S. Supreme Court has taken asset-shifting seriously in bankruptcy. It held that draining a company's money into other companies the owner controlled, so the company couldn't pay a creditor, can count as actual fraud, so the resulting debt may survive the owner's personal bankruptcy even without a direct lie[6]. The Court sent that case back without deciding the final outcome, and the creditor still had to prove fraud and meet bankruptcy deadlines.
The leading California veil-piercing case is cited for its test, not as a win: the court refused to disregard the company there[3]. Expect a judge to want real evidence, such as mixed personal and company money or a company used as an empty shell.
How it works in your state
Licensing boards care about this pattern. A report that links the new business to the old license history gives the board something concrete to check. In Florida, letting someone else use a license is itself grounds for discipline[7]. If the new business is borrowing a relative's or friend's license, see working under someone else's license.
Recovery funds can still help if the contractor was licensed when you hired them. Virginia's fund, for example, can pay a homeowner who holds an unpaid judgment against a licensed contractor for improper or dishonest conduct on their home, but the conduct must have happened while the contractor was licensed, and you must first try to find and collect the contractor's assets[8]. Pick your state below to see your licensing board and whether your state has a fund.
Mistakes that hurt your case
Speed and proof matter more here than in most contractor disputes, because money can move fast.
- Waiting months while assets move and transfer deadlines run
- Suing only the new company without evidence linking it to the old one
- Posting accusations online that you can't prove, instead of sticking to facts
- Ignoring a bankruptcy filing, which can pause collection and has strict deadlines
- Letting your claim against the original company lapse
Your state's rules, with sources
Pick your state to see the rules that matter here, each linked to its official source.
What to gather
Tick things off as you collect them. Your list stays on this device only.
What to do, step by step
- 1
Confirm who you contracted with
Check your contract and the state's business records to see whether the old business was a sole proprietor, LLC or corporation. That answer shapes every other step.
- 2
Research the new business
Look up the new name in your state's business registry and license lookup. Note owners, officers, addresses and license numbers, and save dated screenshots.
- 3
Preserve proof of overlap
Photograph trucks and signs, save ads and websites, and keep any messages that came from the same phone or email. This evidence can disappear quickly.
- 4
Report to the licensing board
File a complaint that names both businesses and the owner, and explain the link. Include the license history and your proof. See how to file a board complaint.
- 5
Send a written demand
Send a demand to the original company and to the owner. OwnersBack Dispute Prep can organize your records into a dated timeline, evidence index and a demand letter you send in your own name.
- 6
Get a judgment against the original company
If the amount fits, small claims court may be the fastest route. A judgment lets you use collection tools and may qualify you for a recovery fund.
- 7
Talk to a lawyer about reaching the new business
Successor liability, fraudulent transfer and veil-piercing claims are fact-heavy. A lawyer can tell you whether your evidence is strong enough and how short your deadlines are.
When to talk to a lawyer now
- The owner moved trucks, equipment, money or jobs to the new company
- You already have a judgment the original company won't pay
- The contractor or the owner has filed for bankruptcy
- Your loss is large enough to justify suing the owner personally
Turn this into a plan you can act on
We turn your paperwork, photos and messages into a dated timeline, an evidence index, a step-by-step plan and a demand letter. A person on our team checks every one.
Hiring someone new to finish the job? Check their bid for free before you sign.
Common follow-up questions
Can I sue the new company for what the old one owes me?
Sometimes, but not just because the same person runs it. Courts generally require one of the narrow exceptions, such as a mere continuation of the old company or a transfer of assets to escape debts[1]. Each state applies these rules its own way.
Can I sue the owner personally?
Possibly. If the old business was a sole proprietorship, the owner usually is the business. If it was an LLC or corporation, you generally need veil piercing or proof the owner personally took part in the wrongdoing. See suing the owner of an LLC.
What if the contractor filed bankruptcy before reopening?
A bankruptcy filing generally pauses lawsuits and collection against the person or company that filed[9]. Some debts, such as those from fraud, may survive, but you usually must act within strict deadlines. See what to do if your contractor files bankruptcy.
Is it illegal to reopen under a new name after losing a license?
Reopening a business isn't illegal by itself, but doing licensed work without a valid license often is. In Arizona, acting as a contractor without a license is a class 1 misdemeanor[10]. Report the new business to your licensing board either way.
How do I find out who owns the new company?
Search your state's business registry for the company's filings, officers and registered agent, and search the license lookup for the owner's name. Court records may also show lawsuits against the owner under either business name.
Laws and cases on this page
Each one was read on its source and checked on November 19, 2026.
- 1
Court decision · CA · Supreme Court of California
Ray v. Alad Corp., 19 Cal. 3d 22 (1977)
What it says
Normally a company that buys another company's assets does not inherit its debts. The California Supreme Court restated the four traditional exceptions: the buyer agreed to take on the debts, the deal was really a merger, the buyer is a "mere continuation" of the seller, or the assets were moved to escape the seller's debts. In this case none of the four applied; the injured plaintiff won only under a new "product line" rule for a buyer that keeps making the seller's product line.
Keep in mind: California Supreme Court case about a defective ladder (strict product liability), not a construction dispute. The product line rule is tied to a successor that keeps making the predecessor's products, so it is unlikely to help in a contractor dispute. The four traditional exceptions are widely used, but each state applies them its own way.
- 2
Statute · FL
Fla. Stat. § 726.105
What it says
Florida law lets a creditor (including a homeowner with a claim or judgment) undo a transfer made with intent to hinder, delay, or defraud creditors. Courts look at warning signs such as transfers to insiders like relatives, transfers made after the debtor was sued or threatened with suit, transfers of nearly all assets, and hidden assets.
Keep in mind: Florida statute (part of Florida's Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act). Deadlines are short: a claim based on actual intent generally must be brought within 4 years after the transfer or, if later, within 1 year after it was or reasonably could have been discovered (§ 726.110). Most states have a similar law, often called the Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, but section numbers, deadlines and details differ.
- 3
Court decision · CA · California Court of Appeal, First District
Associated Vendors, Inc. v. Oakland Meat Co., 210 Cal. App. 2d 825 (1962)
What it says
A court can ignore a company's separate existence and hold the owner personally responsible ("piercing the corporate veil" or "alter ego") when the owner and the company are not really separate and letting the owner hide behind the company would be unfair. This is a leading California case that lists the two things a court looks for.
Keep in mind: California Court of Appeal case about a meat business, not a construction job. In this case the court affirmed the trial court's refusal to disregard the corporation, so the alter ego claim lost; the case is cited for the test, not as a win. Veil piercing is hard to win and depends on many facts, such as mixing personal and company money or using the company as a shell. Other states use similar but not identical tests.
- 4
Court decision · WA · Washington Supreme Court
Grayson v. Nordic Construction Co., 92 Wn.2d 548, 599 P.2d 1271 (1979)
What it says
A roofing company took a payment, tore off part of a house, never finished, and later went bankrupt. The Washington Supreme Court held the company's president personally liable because he took part in the company's unfair and deceptive conduct under the state Consumer Protection Act, even though the court did not pierce the corporate veil.
Keep in mind: Washington Supreme Court case under Washington's Consumer Protection Act. The officer must have personally participated in or knowingly approved the wrongful conduct. Other states have different rules on officer liability.
- 5
Court decision · IL · Supreme Court of Illinois
Vernon v. Schuster, 179 Ill. 2d 338, 688 N.E.2d 1172 (1997)
What it says
Homeowners who had paid a heating business for a boiler and warranty tried to hold the owner's son responsible after he took over the same business under the same name. The Illinois Supreme Court said no: the "mere continuation" rule looks at whether the same owners continue the same company, not just whether the same kind of business keeps running.
Keep in mind: Illinois Supreme Court case involving sole proprietorships after the owner died, not a contractor who closed a company on purpose. It shows that simply reopening under a relative's name does not automatically make the new business liable; a fraud or fraudulent transfer claim may be needed instead. Other states may differ.
- 6
Court decision · Federal · Supreme Court of the United States
Husky International Electronics, Inc. v. Ritz, No. 15-145 (U.S. 2016)
What it says
A business owner drained his company's money into other companies he controlled so it could not pay a creditor. The U.S. Supreme Court held that this kind of asset-shifting scheme can count as "actual fraud," so the resulting debt may survive the owner's personal bankruptcy even if he never told the creditor a lie.
Keep in mind: U.S. Supreme Court case under federal bankruptcy law; it applies nationwide but only decides what counts as "actual fraud." The Court reversed and sent the case back to the lower court; it did not decide whether this particular debt was "obtained by" the scheme and so survived bankruptcy. The creditor still has to prove the fraud in bankruptcy court and meet bankruptcy deadlines. The facts involved an electronics supplier, not a homeowner. The page shows the citation as 578 U.S. ___.
- 7
Statute · FL
Fla. Stat. § 489.129
What it says
Florida's construction licensing board can discipline a contractor, including revoking or suspending the license, fining up to $10,000 per violation, and ordering restitution to the customer. Grounds include abandoning a job (presumed after 90 days without just cause), mismanagement that causes the customer financial harm, and helping an unlicensed person or letting someone else use the license.
Keep in mind: Florida law only, and it applies to state-certified or registered contractors. Board discipline is separate from a lawsuit for your money. Other states' licensing laws list different grounds and penalties.
- 8
Statute · VA
Va. Code § 54.1-1120
What it says
Virginia's Contractor Transaction Recovery Fund can pay a homeowner who holds an unpaid court judgment (or confirmed arbitration award) against a licensed contractor for improper or dishonest conduct on work for the homeowner's residence. You must file within 12 months after the judgment becomes final and first try to find and collect the contractor's assets.
Keep in mind: Virginia only. The conduct must have happened while the contractor was licensed and be related to a contracting transaction. Some people cannot claim, including the contractor's employees, vendors, spouse or children, other licensees, lenders and people in the construction or development business. If the contractor filed bankruptcy, you must first file in the bankruptcy court and then file with the Board within 12 months of the discharge or dismissal. Payment amounts are capped under a separate section, so check how much the fund can pay.
- 9
Statute · Federal
Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. § 362(a) (automatic stay)
What it says
Once a contractor files bankruptcy, an automatic stay generally stops you from starting or continuing a lawsuit against them or trying to collect a debt that arose before the filing. You can ask the bankruptcy court to lift the stay for cause.
Keep in mind: The stay protects the debtor who filed. Whether it reaches a separate company, owner or bond depends on the facts, so check before you act.
- 10
Statute · AZ
Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 32-1164
What it says
In Arizona, acting as a contractor without a license is a class 1 misdemeanor, which is a crime.
Keep in mind: Arizona only. This is a criminal penalty (minimum fine $1,000 for a first offense, $2,000 for a repeat offense); it does not by itself get your money back. Some work is exempt from licensing under a different section of Arizona law, so check whether the job needed a license.
Read next
- Can I sue the contractor personally if they have an LLC?
- I won against my contractor but they won't pay. How do I collect?
- My contractor went out of business in the middle of my job
- My contractor filed for bankruptcy. Can I still get my money back?
- How do I check a contractor's license and complaint history?
Legal information, not legal advice
This page explains the law in general terms so you can understand your options. It isn't legal advice for your situation, and reading it doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and differ by state, and the facts of your case matter. OwnersBack isn't a law firm. Before you sue, sign a settlement, or miss a deadline, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.