Repairs and warranty · Windows
Grace’s new windows leaked in the first big storm. Everyone said it was someone else’s problem.
The installer said it was the window. The window company said it was the install. Here’s how Grace got both of them to look at the same leak, before the labor warranty ran out.
4 min read
This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.
On this page
Twelve windows and a lifetime warranty
Grace replaced twelve old windows for $18,600. The salesperson talked a lot about the lifetime warranty, and the brochure said it in large letters. The crew finished in two days and cleaned up well.
The windows looked great through the fall and winter. Grace paid the final bill and filed the paperwork in a drawer.
A wet sill, a stained wall and two different answers
Ten months later, a long spring storm blew rain against the back of the house. The next morning, two windows on that side had water on the sills, and the drywall under one of them had a brown stain.
Grace called the installer. The office said it sounded like a problem with the window itself, so she should call the manufacturer. The manufacturer’s customer line said water around the edge of a window is usually an installation problem, so she should call the installer.
After the second call, Grace stopped calling and got out the paperwork.
What the warranty actually said
- Product
- “Lifetime limited warranty on window units per manufacturer’s terms.”
- Installation
- “Installer warrants workmanship for one (1) year from completion.”
There were two warranties, not one. The lifetime warranty came from the manufacturer and covered the windows themselves. The installer’s warranty covered the installation, and it ran for one year. Grace was in month ten.
That date mattered. The Federal Trade Commission’s guide to warranties says that if you report a problem during the warranty period and it isn’t properly fixed, the company should correct it even if the warranty runs out first. So the first job was to report the leak in writing, with a date on it, before the year was up.
The FTC also suggests starting with the seller, then writing to the manufacturer at the address in the warranty by certified mail with a return receipt. Grace did both in the same week.
What to ask
What to ask when new windows leak
Put these in writing to the installer and to the manufacturer. Attach dated photos and a short video taken while it was raining.
- Is this leak covered by your installation warranty, and when can you come look at it?
- Can your installer and the manufacturer’s rep look at it together, on the same visit?
- How were these windows flashed and sealed, and what products were used?
- If the window itself is at fault, will you file the claim with the manufacturer, or should I?
- Who repairs the drywall and paint that the water damaged?
Get it in writing
What to get in writing next time
- Both warranties, product and labor, with how long each one lasts and what each covers.
- A copy of the manufacturer’s warranty before you sign, not after.
- Who files a warranty claim, and who you call first if something goes wrong.
- How the windows will be flashed and sealed into the wall.
- Whether the product warranty needs to be registered, and who registers it.
Next step
Grace’s next step, and yours
Grace sent one letter to the installer and one to the manufacturer, each with the photos, the video and the dates. She asked for a joint visit by a set date. The installer came back with the manufacturer’s rep. They found gaps in the sealant along the top of both windows, and the installer resealed them and patched the drywall under the labor warranty.
If an installer won’t come back, our page on what to do when a contractor won’t honor a warranty covers the next steps, and how to document the problem helps you build the record. Some states require you to give a contractor written notice and a chance to repair before you sue. See right to repair notice laws.
If you’re comparing window quotes now, look at the warranty lines first. Our free check points out what a quote says about labor, product and who handles claims.
Have a bid or contract in hand?
Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.
Want a person to read every line?
Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.
See Bid ReviewQuestions people ask
Who is responsible for a leaking new window, the installer or the manufacturer?
It depends on where the water gets in. Leaks around the edge of a window often trace back to how it was installed. Leaks through the window itself can be a product problem. Asking both to look at the same leak together is often the fastest way to an answer.
What can I do if my window installer won’t come back?
Send a written request with photos and a deadline, and keep a copy. If that doesn’t work, the usual next steps are a demand letter, a licensing complaint and small claims court. See when a contractor won’t fix mistakes and writing a demand letter.
Is a lifetime window warranty the same as an installation warranty?
Usually not. A lifetime warranty often covers only the window unit from the manufacturer. The installation is usually covered by a separate, shorter warranty from the installer. Read both before you sign.
Sources
Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.
More stories
General information, not legal advice
These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.