Change orders · Basement
Teresa’s final bill had $4,200 she didn’t remember agreeing to
The basement looked great. The last invoice had six new lines, each marked “per conversation.” Some of those conversations happened. Some Teresa didn’t remember. Here’s how she sorted it out.
4 min read
This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.
On this page
A smooth job with a lot of hallway decisions
Teresa hired a contractor to finish her basement for $41,000: framing, drywall, a small bathroom, flooring and lights. The crew was good, and the contractor was easy to reach.
Like most jobs, it changed along the way. Teresa okayed an extra outlet by the TV. The contractor suggested a better vapor barrier. A few times, a crew member asked a quick question on the stairs and Teresa said “sure, that sounds fine.”
Nobody wrote anything down. It didn’t feel necessary. Everyone was getting along.
The invoice that didn’t match her memory
The final invoice came to $45,200. Six new lines added up to $4,200, each one labeled “per conversation.”
Teresa clearly remembered two of them, the outlet and the vapor barrier. She half remembered a third. The other three, a wider doorway, extra recessed lights and a soffit, she didn’t remember discussing at all.
She didn’t think anyone was making things up. Quick yeses on the stairs are easy to remember differently. But she wasn’t sure what she owed, and that’s a hard place to be at the end of a good job.
What the contract said about changes
- Changes
- “Any change to the scope of work must be in writing and signed by both parties before the work is performed.”
- Final invoice, line 4
- “Add (3) recessed lights per conversation: $780.”
Here’s the good news. The contract had a clear change clause, and that’s a strong start. It’s also the part both sides had skipped.
Some states put this in law too. California, for example, requires change orders in writing that describe the change, the cost added or subtracted, and the effect on the payment schedule. See our California rules, or check your state.
A missing change order doesn’t decide who’s right. It just means the two of you need to rebuild the record together. Our page on change orders that weren’t in writing explains how that usually goes.
What to ask
What to ask about extra charges on a final bill
Ask for the details first. It’s easier to talk about a list than a total.
- Can you list each extra with the date it was discussed and who okayed it?
- How was each price figured: materials, hours and markup?
- Was any of this work already part of the original scope or allowances?
- Can we pay the items we both agree on now, and talk through the rest?
- Would you put each agreed item on a change order we both sign, so our records match?
Get it in writing
What to get in writing next time
- A short change order for every change, even small ones, signed before the work.
- The price of the change, or how it will be priced, and any change to the finish date.
- A running total of approved changes, sent with each invoice.
- A rule for quick on-site questions: “Text me the price first, and I’ll reply yes.”
- The contractor’s markup on extras, stated in the contract.
Next step
How Teresa settled it, and your next step
Teresa paid the original price plus the two extras she clearly remembered, the same day. In a calm email, she asked about the other four. The contractor sent a breakdown. They agreed the soffit had been needed to hide ductwork, which made sense once explained. They split the difference on the lights and dropped the doorway charge. Total paid for extras: $2,650.
If your final bill looks higher than you expected, our pages on a final bill higher than the estimate and verbal agreements with a contractor go further.
Starting a new job? Check that your bid has a change clause before you sign. The free check flags it if it’s missing.
Have a bid or contract in hand?
Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.
Want a person to read every line?
Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.
See Bid ReviewQuestions people ask
Do I have to pay for extra work I didn’t approve in writing?
It depends on your contract, your state and what was said. A verbal okay can still count in some cases. Ask for an itemized list, pay what you both agree on, and talk through the rest in writing. See change orders not in writing.
What should a change order include?
What’s changing, the price added or taken off, any change to the schedule, and both signatures, before the work is done. Our guide to change orders has a fuller list.
Sources
Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.
More stories
General information, not legal advice
These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.