Liens · Patio
Kevin paid the patio contractor in full. Then a supplier filed a lien.
The patio was done and paid for. Six weeks later, a letter said a concrete supplier had recorded a $6,300 lien on the house. Here’s what Kevin learned, and the one envelope he wishes he’d opened sooner.
5 min read
This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.
On this page
A patio, a retaining wall and a paid invoice
Kevin hired a contractor to build a concrete patio and a short retaining wall for $28,000. The work was solid, the crew cleaned up, and the city inspection passed.
Kevin paid each invoice on time, and the final one the day the job was done. He got a thank-you text and a warranty letter. Job closed.
Early in the job, a letter had come from a concrete supply company he’d never heard of. It looked like a form. Kevin put it in a drawer.
The letter six weeks later
Six weeks after the final payment, a second letter came from the same supplier. This one said they had recorded a mechanic’s lien on Kevin’s property for $6,300 in unpaid concrete.
Kevin’s first reaction was “but I paid.” He had. The contractor may have paid too, late, or there may have been a mix-up between the contractor and the supplier. Kevin didn’t know yet, and he didn’t need to guess.
What he needed was to understand the paper, and to move quickly, because liens have deadlines on both sides.
What the paperwork said
- First letter (early in the job)
- “Preliminary Notice: this is not a lien. This notice is to inform you that the supplier named below has furnished materials to your project.”
- Contract notice
- “Even if you pay your contractor in full, a subcontractor or supplier who is not paid may record a lien on your property.”
That first letter was a Preliminary Notice. In California, subcontractors and suppliers serve one within 20 days of starting work or delivering materials to keep their full lien rights. It isn’t an accusation. It’s a heads-up that someone besides your contractor is owed money for your job.
The contract also included the lien notice California requires in home improvement contracts. Kevin had signed past it, like most people do.
California also sets deadlines for the supplier. A lien generally must be recorded within 90 days after the work is completed, and the claimant must file a lawsuit to enforce it within 90 days after recording. The California rules page has the details and the official links. If you’re in another state, the timing differs, so check your state.
What to ask
What to ask when a lien shows up after you paid
Ask the contractor first, in writing, then the supplier. Keep copies of everything.
- Did you pay this supplier for the materials on my job? Can you send the proof of payment?
- Can you get me an unconditional lien release from the supplier for my job?
- If there’s a dispute between you and the supplier, how will you resolve it, and by what date?
- To the supplier: what exactly is unpaid, for which deliveries, and to which address?
- Has a lawsuit been filed to enforce the lien, and if so, when?
Get it in writing
What to get in writing next time
- A list of the subcontractors and suppliers on your job, at the start.
- A conditional lien release from each one before you make a payment, and an unconditional release after.
- Joint checks to the contractor and a major supplier, when a big delivery is involved.
- The right to hold the next payment until you have the releases for the last one.
- Every Preliminary Notice you receive, matched to a release before the final payment.
Next step
How Kevin cleared it, and your next step
Kevin sent the contractor a short email with a copy of the lien, asking for proof of payment or an unconditional release within ten days. The contractor called the same day. A payment to the supplier had been applied to the wrong job. The contractor sorted it out with the supplier, who recorded a release of the lien two weeks later. Kevin kept copies of all of it with his house papers.
Not every lien clears that easily. Our pages on a subcontractor lien after paying your contractor, removing a mechanic’s lien and lien releases and waivers explain the next steps if it doesn’t.
Planning a job now? Ask how lien releases will work before you sign. The free check notes whether your bid mentions them.
Have a bid or contract in hand?
Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.
Want a person to read every line?
Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.
See Bid ReviewQuestions people ask
Can a supplier put a lien on my house if I paid my contractor in full?
In many states, yes, if the supplier followed the notice rules and deadlines. California’s state board says so in its homeowner guidance. Lien releases and joint checks are the usual ways to prevent it. See lien after paying the contractor.
What is a preliminary notice?
A letter from a subcontractor or supplier saying they worked on or supplied your job. In California it’s served within 20 days of starting work or delivering materials. It isn’t a lien. Keep it, and ask for that company’s release before your final payment.
What’s the difference between a conditional and an unconditional lien release?
A conditional release takes effect once the payment actually clears. An unconditional release says the company has been paid. Collect a conditional one before you pay, and the unconditional one after. Our page on lien releases explains more.
Sources
Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.
More stories
General information, not legal advice
These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.