Skip to content
OwnersBack

Payments · Roofing

After the storm, the roofer asked for the full price in cash

The roof was leaking, the price was fair and the cash discount was real. Luis and Ana still paused before handing over $15,900. One short conversation got them a better plan.

5 min read

This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.

On this page
  1. A leak, a knock on the door and a good price
  2. The pause before the bank
  3. What the estimate said
  4. What to ask when a roofer wants full payment up front
  5. What to get in writing
  6. What they agreed to, and your next step
  7. Questions people ask
  8. Sources

A leak, a knock on the door and a good price

A storm took shingles off Luis and Ana’s roof, and the back bedroom ceiling started to stain. Two days later, a roofer knocked on the door. They were working on a house down the street and had seen the damage.

The roofer was friendly, climbed up, took photos and gave a written estimate the same afternoon: $16,800 for a full replacement. Luis and Ana got a second estimate later that week. It was close to the first one.

Then the first roofer offered a deal: $15,900 if they paid the whole price in cash before the crew started. “Saves us card fees and paperwork,” the roofer said, “and gets you on the schedule this week.”

The pause before the bank

Cash discounts are common, and $900 is real money. Luis was ready to go to the bank.

Ana asked one thing first: “If we pay everything now, what do we have if something comes up?” With all the money paid, there’d be no payment left to tie to a finished, inspected roof.

So they called the roofer back, said they wanted to hire them, and asked about the payment plan instead.

What the estimate said

From the paperwork
Payment
“100% due at signing. Cash price: $15,900.”
Permit
“Permit to be pulled by contractor.”
Start
“Start within 7 to 10 days of payment.”

Good signs first: the roofer offered to pull the permit and gave a start window. Both are worth keeping.

Florida has rules that touch this. If a contractor takes more than 10% of the price as a first payment on residential work, it must apply for the permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after the permits are issued, unless there’s just cause or you agreed in writing to a longer time. If you sign a roof contract within 180 days of a declared state of emergency for your area, you can cancel it within 10 days without penalty. And Florida roofers can’t offer a rebate, gift, cash or a waived insurance deductible for a roof inspection or claim. See our Florida contractor rules.

If the sale started at your door, the federal Cooling-Off Rule may also give you until midnight of the third business day to cancel. It has exceptions, such as emergency repairs you asked for. None of this means the roofer did anything wrong. It means the details are worth asking about. Compare deposit rules on our deposit limits by state page.

What to ask

What to ask when a roofer wants full payment up front

You can ask these in a friendly way. Most good roofers have heard them before.

  1. Would you take a deposit now, with the rest when the roof passes final inspection?
  2. Can I pay by check or card so we both have a record, even if I lose the cash discount?
  3. What’s your license number, and what name is it under? I’ll check it on the state site.
  4. When will you apply for the permit, and can you send me the permit number?
  5. Who’s your shingle supplier, and can you send lien releases when they’re paid?
  6. What warranty do you give on the work, and is it in the contract?

Get it in writing

What to get in writing

  • A deposit amount and what it pays for, like the materials order.
  • The rest due after the final inspection passes, not before work starts.
  • Who pulls the permit, and a start date tied to it.
  • The license number, the business name and proof of insurance.
  • A receipt for every payment, with the date and the amount.
  • The workmanship warranty, in years, and what it covers.

Next step

What they agreed to, and your next step

The roofer was fine with it. They settled on a deposit to order materials, a second payment when the old roof was off and the deck was checked, and the last third after final inspection. They paid by check and gave up part of the discount. Ana checked the license on the state’s site the same night.

Being asked for cash or the full price isn’t proof of anything. It just moves the risk to you. Our pages on a contractor who wants cash, paying ahead of the work and roofers who follow storms cover what to do in each case.

Have a roofing estimate in hand? Our free roofing check reads it and shows the payment, permit and warranty lines to ask about before you sign.

Have a bid or contract in hand?

Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.

Want a person to read every line?

Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.

See Bid Review

Questions people ask

Is it normal to pay a roofer up front?

A deposit is common, often to order materials. Paying the whole price before work starts is less common and leaves you with nothing tied to the finished roof. Ask for the rest after final inspection.

Why do some contractors want cash?

Often for simple reasons like card fees. Cash is still hard to trace if something comes up later. If you pay cash, get a signed, dated receipt each time. See when a contractor wants cash.

How much can a Florida contractor take as a first payment?

Florida doesn’t set a simple cap for most jobs, but if a contractor takes more than 10% up front on residential work, it must apply for permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after the permits are issued, with some exceptions. See our Florida rules.

Sources

Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.

  1. Florida Statutes 489.126: money received by contractors
  2. Florida Statutes 489.147: roofing contracts and storm repairs
  3. Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation: file a complaint
  4. Federal Trade Commission: the Cooling-Off Rule

General information, not legal advice

These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.

Roofer wants full payment upfront in cash? What Luis and Ana asked | OwnersBack