Price and budget · Kitchen
Joan and Mike’s kitchen ran $16,000 over, one allowance at a time
The bid was the lowest of three. By the time the cabinets, tile and lights were picked, the kitchen was $16,000 over. Nobody hid anything. It was all in the allowances.
4 min read
This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.
On this page
Three bids and an easy choice
Joan and Mike got three bids for a full kitchen remodel. Two came in around $60,000. The third was $52,000, from a contractor with great reviews and a clear, well-organized bid. It felt like an easy choice.
The contract listed the work in detail. For the things they hadn’t picked yet, it listed allowances: a set amount for cabinets, tile, lighting and the sink and faucet.
Demolition and rough-in went smoothly. Then it was time to choose finishes.
The cabinet quote
Joan and Mike went to the cabinet showroom the contractor recommended. They picked a mid-range line, nothing fancy. The quote came back at $14,600.
The cabinet allowance was $8,000. Tile, lights and fixtures went the same way, a little at a time. None of their choices felt extravagant. Each one was a few thousand over.
When the contractor sent the allowance summary, the overages plus markup came to just under $16,000. The kitchen was now more expensive than the two bids they’d passed on.
What the allowances said
- Allowances
- “Cabinets: $8,000 (material only). Tile: $2,500. Lighting fixtures: $1,200. Sink and faucet: $900.”
- Overages
- “Selections exceeding allowance will be billed at cost plus 20%.”
Credit where it’s due: this contract was clear. It named every allowance, said cabinets were material only, and stated the markup. Many bids say less.
The issue was the numbers. An $8,000 cabinet allowance was low for a kitchen that size, and a 20% markup on every overage adds up. That’s often why bids differ: one contractor plans for typical finishes, another leaves room for you to choose and pay later.
It’s also why comparing totals can mislead. The two higher bids had cabinet allowances of $13,000 and $14,000. Lined up the same way, the three bids were much closer than they looked. Our bid comparison spreadsheet has a row for each allowance so you can see that before you sign.
What to ask
What to ask about allowances before you sign
Ask these for each allowance on the bid. It takes ten minutes and can save thousands.
- What would this allowance buy, in a brand or line you’d suggest? Can I see an example?
- Is installation labor included, or only the material?
- If I go over, how is the difference billed? Is there a markup, and how much?
- If I spend less, do I get the difference back?
- When do I need to make each choice so the schedule doesn’t slip?
Get it in writing
What to get in writing
- Each allowance as a dollar amount, and whether it includes labor.
- The markup on overages, or that there isn’t one.
- A credit for any amount you don’t use.
- A running allowance summary with each invoice.
- A signed change order for every overage before the item is ordered.
Next step
What Joan and Mike did, and your next step
They sat down with the contractor and the allowance sheet. They kept the cabinets, switched to a simpler tile, and moved two light fixtures to “later.” The contractor agreed to drop the markup on the cabinet overage, since the showroom was their suggestion. The final number came in about $10,500 over the original bid, with every change signed.
If your project is drifting over budget, our page on a final bill higher than the estimate covers your options, and our guide on what an estimate should include has a section on allowances. Comparing bids now? Read how to compare two contractor estimates.
Before you sign a kitchen bid, run it through our free kitchen check. It points out low allowances and markup terms so you can ask about them first.
Have a bid or contract in hand?
Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.
Want a person to read every line?
Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.
See Bid ReviewQuestions people ask
What is an allowance in a construction contract?
A placeholder amount for things you haven’t chosen yet, like cabinets or tile. If your choice costs more, you usually pay the difference, sometimes with a markup. If it costs less, you may get a credit, if the contract says so.
How do I know if an allowance is too low?
Price the items you actually want before you sign, at a store or showroom. Compare each allowance across bids, line by line. Our bid comparison spreadsheet makes that easy.
Sources
Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.
More stories
General information, not legal advice
These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.