Repairs and warranty · Flooring
Sophie’s new floors were almost done. The contractor wanted the last $3,080 first.
The crew packed up with a short list of things left to fix. The contractor said to pay first and they’d be back next week. Here’s how Sophie got the list finished.
4 min read
This is a composite story, built from common situations homeowners describe. Names and details are illustrative.
On this page
A new floor through the whole first floor
Sophie hired a flooring contractor to put new hardwood through her first floor for $15,400. The contract called for 80% as the work went and the last 20%, $3,080, at completion.
The crew worked steadily for two weeks. The floor looked beautiful from the front door. On the last afternoon, the lead installer said they were done and the office would send the final invoice.
A walk through the house with a pad of sticky notes
That evening, Sophie walked every room slowly. She found gaps between boards near the kitchen, two boards with deep scratches in the hallway, no transition strip at the bathroom door, no trim along one wall in the dining room and small bubbles in the finish by the stairs.
She put a sticky note on each spot and took photos. The next morning, the invoice arrived. When she mentioned the list, the office said to pay the final invoice and they’d send someone back next week for touch-ups.
Sophie had nothing against a return visit. She just wanted the order to be the other way around.
What the contract said about the final payment
- Payment
- “Final payment of 20% due upon completion.”
- Scope
- “Install hardwood flooring, main level. Includes trim and transitions as needed.”
The contract said the last payment was due at completion, but it didn’t say what completion meant. There was no walkthrough and no punch list step. The scope did include trim and transitions, and two of those were missing.
The Federal Trade Commission advises never making the final payment until the work is done and you’re satisfied with it. The New York Attorney General’s guide to hiring a contractor says the same thing: hold the final payment until the whole project is complete.
Holding back money is still a step to take with care. Hold an amount that fairly matches what’s left, say why in writing and pay promptly once the list is done. In some states, a contractor who isn’t paid may file a lien, so a clear written record matters.
What to ask
What to ask when the contractor wants the final payment first
Put your list in writing with numbered items and photos. Then ask these questions in the same message.
- Which items on this list will you fix, and on what date?
- Will the same crew come back, and how long will the fixes take?
- How will you fix the gaps: fill them or replace the boards?
- Will the touch-ups match the finish on the rest of the floor?
- Would you agree that I pay part of the final now and the rest when the list is done?
Get it in writing
What to get in writing next time
- What counts as complete: a walkthrough together and a signed punch list.
- An amount held back until the punch list is finished.
- Every part of the scope spelled out, including trim, transitions and thresholds.
- How many coats of finish, and how long before you can walk on it or move furniture back.
- What the warranty covers if boards gap or lift in the first year.
Next step
Sophie’s next step, and yours
Sophie emailed a numbered list with photos and offered to pay $2,000 of the final right away and the last $1,080 when the list was done. The contractor agreed. The crew came back the next week, replaced the two scratched boards, filled the gaps, added the trim and the transition and buffed out the finish by the stairs. Sophie paid the rest that day.
If a contractor won’t come back, our page on what to do when a contractor won’t fix mistakes walks through the next steps. Before you hold money, read how to hold a payment carefully, and if a lien comes up, see when a contractor threatens a lien.
If you’re about to sign, look at how the contract defines the end of the job. Our free check points out when the final payment is due and whether there’s a punch list step.
Have a bid or contract in hand?
Our Free Bid Check reads it in about a minute and shows the biggest things to ask about, quoted from your own pages. No account needed.
Want a person to read every line?
Bid Review is $99. We check your bid against the 37-item OwnersBack Checklist and your state's rules, a real person on our team signs off, and it's back in two business days.
See Bid ReviewQuestions people ask
Should I pay the final payment before the punch list is done?
The FTC advises not making the final payment until the work is done and you’re satisfied. Many homeowners hold an amount that matches the open items and pay the rest. See paying for unfinished work.
What is a punch list?
It’s a list of small items left to fix or finish at the end of a job, made during a walkthrough. A good contract says the final payment is due after the punch list is done.
Can a contractor put a lien on my house if I hold back the final payment?
In some states, an unpaid contractor can file a lien, even in a dispute about the quality of the work. Holding only what matches the open items, and putting the reasons in writing, helps. See liens over disputed work.
Sources
Rules change. We link to the official source for every rule we mention, so you can check what applies to you.
More stories
General information, not legal advice
These stories share general information to help you ask good questions. They aren't legal advice, and rules vary by state and city. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or your state's contractor board.