Before you hire
Contractor contract red flags to fix before you sign
Red flags in a contractor contract or bid, and how to fix each one in writing: deposits, cash, license, vague scope, payments, changes, dates and permits.
Updated November 19, 2026 · 8 min read
Most contractors want the same thing you do: a job that goes well and a client who's happy at the end. When a contract has a weak spot, it's usually because the paperwork is rushed or copied from an old template, not because anyone is up to something.
So read this list calmly. Each “red flag” below is just a spot worth a question. For each one, you'll see what it looks like, why it matters and how to fix it in writing. A good contractor will usually be glad to make these fixes.
1. A big deposit
What it looks like: A large share of the price is due at signing, before anything happens on site.
Why it matters: Once most of the money is paid, it's harder to sort out problems. The FTC advises not paying the full amount up front, and some states set a limit. In California, the Contractors State License Board says a home improvement down payment can't be more than $1,000 or 10% of the price, whichever is less. In Maine, the Attorney General explains that contracts over $3,000 must limit deposits to one-third of the price.
How to fix it: Ask what the deposit pays for. If it's for special-order materials, ask to pay that part when the order is placed, with a receipt. Check your state on our deposit limits by state page.
2. Cash only
What it looks like: The contractor asks to be paid only in cash, sometimes for a discount.
Why it matters: The FTC lists cash-only requests as a warning sign. Cash leaves no record, which makes it hard to prove what you paid if a question comes up later.
How to fix it: Pay by check, card or bank transfer. If the contractor prefers cash for small amounts, get a signed, dated receipt every time. Write the payment method into the contract.
3. No license number
What it looks like: The contract has a business name but no license number, or the name doesn't match the license record.
Why it matters: The FTC lists the license number as something your contract should include, and it suggests hiring only licensed and insured contractors. Licensing rules vary by state and trade.
How to fix it: Ask for the license number on the contract, then look it up. Here's how to check a contractor's license, and our contractor rules by state page links to each state's lookup.
4. A vague scope of work
What it looks like: “Remodel kitchen.” “New bathroom.” One line where there should be a list.
Why it matters: If the scope is vague, you and the contractor can both be honest and still remember the deal differently. California's board says a contract should describe in detail the products and how the work will be done, including things like size, color, amounts and model numbers.
How to fix it: Ask for a room-by-room or step-by-step list with quantities and products. Our estimate guide shows what a clear scope looks like.
5. “As needed” and other open-ended words
What it looks like: “Replace subfloor as needed.” “Electrical upgrades as required.”
Why it matters: Sometimes nobody can know the answer until walls are open, so these phrases are honest. But with no price attached, the cost is open-ended.
How to fix it: Ask for a unit price (for example, a price per sheet of subfloor) and a cap, plus a promise to show you photos and a written price before going past it.
6. Payments ahead of the work
What it looks like: Payments due on dates, or most of the money due before the finish work starts.
Why it matters: Payments tied to dates can get ahead of the actual progress. In California, the board says payments can't be more than the value of the work done. The FTC advises holding the final payment until the work is done and you're satisfied.
How to fix it: Tie each payment to a clear stage of finished work, like “cabinets installed” or “rough plumbing passed inspection.” Keep a solid final payment for the end. See understanding contractor payment schedules.
7. No change order process
What it looks like: Nothing about changes, or a line like “extra work billed at our standard rates.”
Why it matters: Changes happen on almost every job. Without a process, extra charges can show up on the next invoice with no warning.
How to fix it: Add a line that says no extra work will be billed without a written change order, signed by both of you before the work starts, showing the price and any schedule change. More in what is a construction change order.
8. No completion date
What it looks like: A start date, or not even that, and no finish date.
Why it matters: The FTC lists estimated start and completion dates as contract items. Without them, there's nothing to point to if the job drifts.
How to fix it: Ask for an estimated start and completion date, a short list of allowed delays (like weather or back-ordered items), and a promise to tell you in writing when the schedule moves.
9. Allowances that look too low
What it looks like: A $1,500 allowance for kitchen lighting when the fixtures you like cost twice that.
Why it matters: Low allowances make a bid look cheaper than the job will really be. The difference shows up later as overages.
How to fix it: Price the items you actually want before you sign, then ask to raise the allowance to match. Also ask whether the allowance includes labor, and how overages and credits are figured.
10. No lien releases
What it looks like: Nothing in the contract about lien releases or proof that subcontractors and suppliers were paid.
Why it matters: In many states, a subcontractor or supplier who isn't paid can file a lien on the property they worked on, even when the problem is between them and your contractor.
How to fix it: Ask for lien releases with each payment. California's board, for example, suggests getting a signed conditional release from possible lien claimants before each payment, and mentions joint checks as a simple way to make sure subcontractors and suppliers get paid.
11. Pressure to sign today
What it looks like: “This price is only good if you sign now.”
Why it matters: The FTC advises not letting anyone pressure you into signing. A day or two to read and compare almost never changes a fair deal.
How to fix it: Ask for the price in writing with a date it's good until. If you do sign at home or somewhere other than the seller's permanent place of business, the FTC's Cooling-Off Rule may give you until midnight of the third business day to cancel. There are exceptions, so ask the contractor to show you the cancellation notice.
12. You're asked to pull the permit
What it looks like: “It's easier if you get the permit as the homeowner.”
Why it matters: The FTC lists a contractor asking you to get the building permits as a warning sign. Getting permits is normally part of the contractor's job, and whoever holds the permit is the person the building department deals with about the work.
How to fix it: Ask the contractor to pull the permits and schedule inspections, with the cost included in the price. Put it in the contract, and tie the final payment to the final inspection.
What to do with what you find
Write down each item, send it to your contractor in one email, and ask for a revised contract or a signed addendum. Keep it friendly. You're both trying to get the paperwork right before work starts.
Our free bid check can spot many of these for you. It flags what's missing, vague or risky, quotes each spot with its page number, and doesn't store your file. If you're still choosing between bids, use the bid comparison spreadsheet and our questions to ask before hiring a contractor. For the full list of what a contract should cover, see our remodeling contract checklist, and if you were handed an estimate to sign, read estimate vs contract.
Want a person to look it over? Our $99 Bid Review checks your bid or contract against a 37-item checklist and your state's rules, with sources, and an experienced reviewer checks every finding.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission — Advice on hiring a home improvement contractor
- California Contractors State License Board — What is a contract?
- California Contractors State License Board — How to prevent a mechanics lien
- Maine Attorney General — Home construction contracts (10 M.R.S. §1487)
- Federal Trade Commission — The Cooling-Off Rule (three days to cancel certain sales)
This guide is general educational information, not legal advice. Rules vary by state and locality. Check with the relevant official agency or a licensed professional.
Have a proposal in hand?
We'll read it line by line and give you a report checked by an experienced reviewer, with the specific questions to ask before you sign or pay.